If he can do nistune RIGHT, that's awesome!Nategreat923 wrote:I appreciate that, but I have a great tuner that does nistune near me
A tuner who can blow an engine with Nistune can blow an engine with anything else. Too much ignition advance will ping regardless of which computer is in charge.MeanGreenS13 wrote:If he can do nistune RIGHT, that's awesome!Nategreat923 wrote:I appreciate that, but I have a great tuner that does nistune near me
I found someone who said they could do nistune also...I ended up with a blown up engine at the end of the whole ordeal. I wish you luck.
I have heard great things about his tunes too. I'm at a cross between UP or Drift Office finishing up my tune. Although I am using Power FC.Nategreat923 wrote:Bob does incredible work. http://Www.driftoffice.com
Nategreat923 wrote:Bob does incredible work. http://Www.driftoffice.com
Considering my friends have been tuned by him, and bouncing rev limiter for the last 4 years without a hiccup, Id say he does incredible work.
Not trying to be confrontational but, all due respect, I can't make sense of your reasoning. The factory ECU has been running these engines flawlessly for over 20 years. What about the addition of the Nistune daughterboard makes it now more prone popping engines?MeanGreenS13 wrote:I am well aware of this... I don't need to be educated, this wasn't my first rodeo lol I can laugh about it now but at the time it royally sucked... Ended up selling the car out of frustration, guy rebuilt the engine and promptly blew it again himself.
Have you ever played with the software for NISTUNE? I don't know how it is now, but the original software with the original nistune build that I had was NOT easy... A buddy of mine that use to work at CFT couldn't even figure some of it out when we were street tuning it. That's why we stopped and took it to the "pros"Buddyworm wrote:Not trying to be confrontational but, all due respect, I can't make sense of your reasoning. The factory ECU has been running these engines flawlessly for over 20 years. What about the addition of the Nistune daughterboard makes it now more prone popping engines?MeanGreenS13 wrote:I am well aware of this... I don't need to be educated, this wasn't my first rodeo lol I can laugh about it now but at the time it royally sucked... Ended up selling the car out of frustration, guy rebuilt the engine and promptly blew it again himself.
And blowing an engine without even touching the timing maps? Impressive. How many PSI on what turbo? Were you tuning AFR's without a wideband or what?? Where was your base timing set at??? Where did it let go? Headgasket or bottom end?
I'm very familiar with Nistune. I've got a few tunes under my belt with this package. Couple basic SR's and some really quick CA's. My own setup I daily a TD06-17C at 1Bar. Besides some worn rings towards the end my engine served me reliably for 3 seasons getting flogged at drift events weekly before it finally let go last October after a friend missed an upshift to 3rd at full bore and smashed into the rev limiter. Went catastrophically lean and vaporized the upper piston ring and cracked a ringland. The fresh build is currently on breakin with CP pistons added to the mix.MeanGreenS13 wrote:Have you ever played with the software for NISTUNE? I don't know how it is now, but the original software with the original nistune build that I had was NOT easy... A buddy of mine that use to work at CFT couldn't even figure some of it out when we were street tuning it. That's why we stopped and took it to the "pros"
I never said there was ANYTHING wrong with nistune as a whole. I'm just saying he needs to make sure that person has experience with it. The old software at least was not easy to work with.
And, If you must know, we were running 15psi on an SC61 and 750cc injectors... Should have had NO issues at all, but there was either a lean spot or a very rich spot in the tune that caused the issue. Blew the rings right out of cyl 1 and 3 and a hole in piston #3. The kicker was it happened at part throttle.
Buddyworm wrote:
A tuner who can blow an engine with Nistune can blow an engine with anything else. Too much ignition advance will ping regardless of which computer is in charge.
This is probably a fairly accurate representation. Once you understand the basics of what tables the ECU accesses under what conditions it becomes pretty straightforward. I've also played with an AEM EMS though. THAT had a lot of parameters to fill in...louiswun wrote:I'm a nistune distributor / board installer and a licenced tuner in Hong Kong.
All I can say is....most of the non nistune tuner is not fully understand what's inside nistune software.
The one who know nistune well, who usually know how to modify the stock rom, I mean the very old method, by using rom reader to extract the rom file and make adjustment to suit the new engine setup, it require the rom tuning knowledge to get the job done perfect.
Actually, the nistune software is only an interface to show the stock rom file, if you do not know how to rom tuning, you will have hard time to tune it to perfect.
Honestly, it is quite tricky to get the tune perfect, I have done RB20, RB25, RB26, SR20 and CA18, dealing with these aged engines, a small trouble will stuck you in the middle of no where, the one who do it good must have to know these engines well, must have to know what cause trouble and must have to know how to fix those trouble.
Especially on CA18 ecu, there is a lean spot while ecu switching from sequential injection to batch injection, you must have to know how to deal with this.
A good nistune tuner can adapt with any brand stand alone ecu in very short time, but a non nistune tuner might not easy to adapt nistune, a stock ecu is far more complicated than most aftermarket stand alone ecu.
This is excellent information to share and glad finally someone took the time to say this stuff.louiswun wrote:I'm a nistune distributor / board installer and a licenced tuner in Hong Kong.
All I can say is....most of the non nistune tuner is not fully understand what's inside nistune software.
The one who know nistune well, who usually know how to modify the stock rom, I mean the very old method, by using rom reader to extract the rom file and make adjustment to suit the new engine setup, it require the rom tuning knowledge to get the job done perfect.
Actually, the nistune software is only an interface to show the stock rom file, if you do not know how to rom tuning, you will have hard time to tune it to perfect.
Honestly, it is quite tricky to get the tune perfect, I have done RB20, RB25, RB26, SR20 and CA18, dealing with these aged engines, a small trouble will stuck you in the middle of no where, the one who do it good must have to know these engines well, must have to know what cause trouble and must have to know how to fix those trouble.
Especially on CA18 ecu, there is a lean spot while ecu switching from sequential injection to batch injection, you must have to know how to deal with this.
A good nistune tuner can adapt with any brand stand alone ecu in very short time, but a non nistune tuner might not easy to adapt nistune, a stock ecu is far more complicated than most aftermarket stand alone ecu.