Kendahl wrote:Even if it is priced fairly, an extended warranty won't help you after it expires. If you plan to keep the car long past that point, I think you will be better off putting the price of the warranty into a savings account with the highest possible interest rate.
I agree, although a "high interest" savings account is earning about 1% these days which is likely to not even keep pace with inflation which essentially erodes the buying power of that cash in the future.
That notwithstanding, extended warranties are generally a bad deal when purchased on, really, anything. Essentially it's just an insurance policy, and insurance companies stay in business by taking in more premiums than they pay out in claims, simple as that. So while any extended warranty will give you piece of mind and protect you from catastrophic loss, the statistical odds are against you that will ever claim more money for repairs than you paid for the insurance policy/extended warranty.
Here are some examples of things off the top of my head I've been offered extended warranties on and didn't purchase... and wouldn't have needed as nothing went wrong before I decided to sell or replace each item.
2002 - old school giant projection TV $400
2002 - vacuum cleaner $30
2003 - desktop computer $225
2004 - laptop computer $200
2005 - new car $1000
2006 - flat panel TV $250
2006 - bigger better vacuum cleaner $60
2007 - another laptop computer $150
2007 - water softener $200
2007 - lawnmower $100
2007 - gas grill $50
...and that's just what I can recall. over $2500 that would have been pissed away if I was fearful that I might have to pay for a repair on an item that is unlikely to break.