Fastforward 2.5 months:
I get this call from this guy who accuses me of stealing a wheel. After he calmed down I asked him for some details. He told me I never shipped the wheel back. I let him know what happened and he said they never received it back and demanded I pay for it. I was irritated at this point and told him I sent it back and graciously repacked it for him at my own expense. He asked me to prove that I sent it by faxing him a copy of my UPS pickup manifest. I don't use UPS and told him what I did. He told me he would sue me. I encouraged him to do so.
He now keeps calling me and keeps making threats. What do you do with arrogant douche bags like this? I could have just kept the wheel and denied ever receiving it, hell I even sell wheels for a living and could have made some good money, - but no, I went out of my way to do the honest thing and this is what I get. To quote Judge Judy: "no good deed ever goes unpunished".
