Q45denver wrote:Increased reliablity of alternator and batttery offsets increased relaibility of engine, injectors, waterpump, hoses, etc?
Getting ANY extra engine/injector/waterpump/hose reliability by installing an electric fan is pure speculation - but the adverse effect it has on alternator and battery reliability is an indisputable fact. Hanging an extra 20-40 amp full-time load on your electrical system WILL shorten the alternator and battery life expectancies.
Quote »A mechanical fan with a clutch is more simple than an electric motor with a thermostat?[/quote]Yep.
A mechanical fan with a clutch is simpler than one or two electric fans, their assocated relay(s), thermostat, fuse/circuit breaker, wiring and connectors.