zozoka1212 wrote:I don't want to start a war. Just to clear couple of things. Winter tires are awesome in snow. Nothing can compare to it. How about winter tire in rain or winter tire on cold dry road?
Unfortunately there is no such a thing as a perfect tires for all weather. Another unfortunate thing is the weather does not cooperate with you. Sometimes you drive in all winter and you see snow few times. Like this season. In this season the winter tires would be performing worse than all season every day.
How many snowing days you have vs. how many no snowing days.
Here is a link. Good reading. Take a look at the braking distance on dry cold road and rainy cold road. Unfortunately the snow tire doesn't do well. On the 60-0 test the all season stopped 30 feet shorter than the winter tire. Now question yourself. If the weather is bad snowing outheer. Are you going to speed or when the road dry? To me the answer is snow I slow down and dry road well go faster.
http://www.caranddriver.com/fe...age_2
I also not really a big fan of the idea of snow and summer tire switch. You'll either end up sing your summer tires when you shouldn't at freezing temp. or you'll use your winter tires in the warm weather. When you shouldn't.
Just my .02 well it is actually .018 since canadian $ worth less.
There is a distinction between winter tires and snow tires. Pilot Alpins are actually pretty crappy in deep snow but are good on cold surfaces, plowed streets with some coating, light snow - the sort of stuff that I've got all winter in upstate NY. You can get winter tires with H+ speed ratings. Snow tires tend to be nobblier, noisier, better in deep snow but not that great on pavement.
http://www.wheels.ca/Tire%20Talk/article/177172
"Of course all this research and technology has improved snow tires, too. So with a snow tire, you still get chunky tread, a bit less stability on the highway and more noise, but you do get snow traction.
With a winter tire, you get quieter ride, very little squirm, less noise than some all-season tires, good pavement ride and grip, long wear characteristics, and – last but not least – good ice and snow traction.
Practical examples from real life: in the Bridgestone Firestone family, the Bridgestone Blizzak is the winter tire, the Firestone Winter Force is the snowtire; in the Michelin/BFG/Uniroyal family, the Michelin X-Ice is the winter tire, and the BFGoodrich Winter Slalom is a snowtire; in the Pirelli world, the Snowsport is a winter tire and the Winter Carving is a snow tire."
My experience was very positive with winter tires over the cooper all-seasons my Audi came with. I've had snows in the past and didn't care for them - maybe if I lived up near lake placid or in Vermont. I also like summer performance tires so I've got to swap out - that meant for me winter tires. On our family BMW X3, we've got all-seasons that stay on year round - they are pretty good.
Peter