DonSherman wrote:Thanks for the input. I did buy 4 -17" wheels and 235/50 Bridgestone Blizzak LM-22 winter tires. I plan to put them on in the fall. I find that winter tires are very worthwhile in both going, and stopping.
An excellent decision!
DonSherman wrote:The question is, should I use the original OEM all season Goodyear tires next spring, or go for summer tires based on OEM Goodyears poor performance in the wet, and their rapid loss of grip even on dry roads as the tread wears down? Tire rack has a lot of info on good summer tires for the M. Can anyone report on their experience in dry & wet roads with summer (high performance or better) summer tires, compared with the OEM Goodyears?
I have directly compared the Goodyear Eagle RS-A (OEM on the non-Sport M) to other brands, like the Goodyear Eagle F1 GS-D3, albeit in different sizes on different cars that I own. The difference is amazing.
The RS-A is a long-lasting, totally mediocre tire. Good in road quietness, but the handling, both in dry and wet, braking, and general "summerishness" of the tire leaves a lot to be desired. Almost any brand of quality summer tire is better. I remain amazed at the high price that this tire commands too!
The Eagle F1 GS-D3 is superior in wet weather, both handling and braking, to most tires sold today. I use it in a 245/45-18 size on my current M45, and in a 205/55-16 on my wife's Acura. It is not the best tire in the world (that, imho, is the now-obsolete Firestone Firehawk SZ50EP), but among the best.
My only compaint with it has been the need for more balancing than I would like. I balance every 2.5k to 3k miles or so on my wife's Acura. I had hoped that I would be able to avoid this on my M (since the load index is 100W and it is a stronger tire), but this has not turned out to be true.
In terms of what I would recommend in a 245/45-18 size, the following are good contenders:
1. Goodyear Eagle F1 GS-D3 245/4-18 100W. A Max Performance Summer tire.
2. Avon Tech M550 A/S 245/45-18 96W. This is a Ultra High-Performance All-Season tire, so not as good a summer tire as their Avon Tech M500, but the M500 is not available in a 245/45-18 size.
3. Bridgestone Potenza RE050 245/45-18 96Y. An excellent, all-round Max Performance Summer tire. Not as good as the Eagle F1 GS-D3 in wet, but very close. I chose the Eagle because of the better wet handling (my particular fear at speed.) This is a Run Flat tire.
4. Bridgestone Potenza S-03 Pole Position 245/45-18 96Y. This has been highly rated at Tire Rack and appears to be an excellent tire. A lot of people have bought them and it is one of the often quoted ones by Tire Rack personnel.
5. Michelin Pilot Sport 245/45-18 100Y. An excellent performer. Some experts here swear by their general quality and Michelin's overall attention to strength and meeting the load index with a lot of margin. Pricy.
6. Yokohama AVS ES100 245/45-18 100W RF. A very good performer according to some people. This is a Run Flat tire, so may have sitffer side-walls than usual. Whether this affects the handling is unclear to me.
7. Pirelli PZero Rosso Asimmetrico 245/45-18 96Y. I think this is a very good tire. A number of people here like Pirelli tires, and Greg (AZhitman) our CEO has them on his Q45 and likes them a lot, I believe.
One of the above will do you very well indeed! The Avon is the lowest cost and is a worthy contender just for that reason alone. I.e., if you do not like it, then getting rid of it is less of a burden.
Hope this points you in the right direction. I intend to update the stickies above soon!
Z