Post by
SX APPEAL »
https://forums.nicoclub.com/sx-appeal-u20552.html
Tue Aug 07, 2012 7:41 pm
I figured this thread would turn into an "I hate NASCAR" bloodbath in about 10 seconds. I'm not the world's biggest nascar fan either, more of an F1 guy myself. But even I can admit that there's more to it than just a bunch of good-ol' boys driving around in circles while a bunch of drunk rednecks yell and fight. And as I'm sure guys like Tony Stewart, Robby Gordon and Juan Pablo Montoya could tell you, it takes just as much skill (albiet a very different kind of skill) to get one of those lumbering hulks around a racetrack fast with 42 other guys trying to do the same thing 6 inches away from you as it does to dance an open wheeled car around a road course.
On the point of nascar getting away from its roots with the cars and such, well yes they no longer even slightly resemble the production cars they represent, but this has been the evolution of another long standing cornerstone of nascar, that the cars should be as equal as possible so the drivers have to separate themselves on the track. This comes down to more than just pure driving talent as well. Nascar machines have no on-board telemetry or data logging capabilities, so in order to set a car up optimally for a given track, the only source of info on how the car is behaving and what needs to be done to improve it is the driver. Therefore the better the driver is at helping the team set up the car, the better chance he has of winning the race.
This is completely contrary to Formula 1, which is less of a driver oriented sport. This is not a stab at F1 either, mind you. As F1 is largely a team vs team competition to see which can build the fastest car and then put the best driver in it. I would bet you anything that if you put Fernando Alonso or Lewis Hamilton or Jenson Button in that beautiful machine Adrian Newey and his guys at Red Bull designed last year, any one of them would've won the championship.There's nothing wrong with this, that's just the way it is, that's why F1 has a Driver's AND a Team's championship.
So if you've already skipped my big rant to get to the next post let me just summarize by saying this: its ignorant to call any motorsport boring and stupid as opposed to another without fully appreciating the qualities of both.
Thank you and goodnight.