stash420sx wrote:hey, if you are able to upload the eprom data i would also be very intrested in seeing that.
2BN_S13 wrote:you guys might want to be more careful about shouting that out so loud. If you copy jwt's .BIN file that could constitute some legal action (maybe, i dont really care but you should watch it any way). I mean they would have to catch you first but thats my thought anyway.
Lost_To_A_K-Car wrote:Originally posted by bruinbear714 "]As long as the person is not making any profit from ripping off the JWT rom data then it is not illegal.
This is incorrect. A noncommercial violation of copyright is still a violation.
Whether or not tuning data is actually subject to copyright protection is another story.
brage wrote:Technically JWT could be brought down by NISSAN by illigally copying NISSAN rom data, modifying it, and making a profit off of selling the MODIFIED product... Similar to say deleting Jar Jar Binks from star wars Ep 1 and selling it...
I don't think e-mailing a JWT ROM consitutes a violation of JWT's right, only NISSAN's
(although they could give a **** less)
C-Kwik wrote:I disagree. JWT is taking a product that is already on the market. Then they are modifying the program. Then selling it as a modified ECU. Once you buy a product, you can do what you want to it(with the exception of non-copyright law infringements). There was a thread on the XBox forum a while back that is similar. It is not illegal to mod the XBox by rechipping it. It is illegal to make copies of the software. It's like saying if I buy a movie on VHS, I am not allowed to tape over what is on the tape.
As far as JWT's rights, I don't see anything wrong with finding out the programming, so long as you are not copying it. And this is all under the pretense that all this stuff has copyrights on it. Who knows if they have even bothered seeing as it doesn't really hurt them much not to copyright the programming. There is not a lot of relative demand for ECU programs and the ability to modify these programs is limited compared to our everyday media. I don't see Nissan or JWT losing much money over the cost of getting a copyright.