Post by
ziggy682 »
https://forums.nicoclub.com/ziggy682-u3095.html
Sat Jul 10, 2004 9:37 pm
Okay, 240Knightrider, I have a question for you.
Do you own a KA-T?
If the answer is no, than everyone should disregard every one of your posts about the subject, because it is your opinion, and not fact.
I personally own a KA-T, which I built myself, so I happen to know a bit about the subject.
Your telling him to spend $1200 building the engine with "forged rods, pistons, and other forged parts". Well, KA's already have forged rods stock, and I'm not sure what "other forged parts" you're talking about. The point is, he is looking "to be around a stock SR in hp rating". Do you know how much a stock SR puts out? I can tell you, it's about 160-170 hp to the wheels. Do you know how much boost it takes a KA to make 160-170 hp to the wheels? Not much...certainly not enough to justify spending $1200 to build the engine with "forged rods, pistons, and other forged parts".
If Structure240sx blew his engine overboosting at 10psi, he probably didn't have enough fuel to support 10psi. If you blow a stock engine from detonation, you will blow a built engine nearly as easy from the same detonation.
As far as your other reccomendation that he "just upgrade the fuel system get headers, intake. Look into getting a performance chip" let's look into that statement a little further.
Intake-A good investment.Headers-Don't know why he would need multiple headers when one header would be just fine.Fuel system-Why would he need that in an N/A application. Seems like a waste of money to me.Performance Chip-Who makes a "performance chip" for the KA? Oh, you must be talking about those Ebay performance timing mod resitor thingies. Yeah, those things work great.With your recommended mods, there's absolutely no reason for him to go turbo. He'll have atleast 250 to the wheels with those mods.:rolleyes
As far as your talk of the N/A KA with more than 200 hp to the wheels, show me one single dyno of an N/A KA making that much power. I've never seen one, and if I did, it would most certainly have more than $1200 into it. 200 hp to the wheels is about 240-250 at the engine. That's nearly a 100 hp gain without forced induction. Good luck with that.
One last quote. He said "all i want is to be around a stock SR in hp rating." You said "if you want power like the SR or above 250." Hmm, I don't think you read his post very well before replying. He only wants around a stock SR power level. Who said anything about 250 or above? Chmercer never did.
The point is, he will be just fine on a stock KA running the 5-7 psi that he wants to run. At that boost level, he will make clost to 230 hp to the wheels, wich is quite a bit above what a stock SR puts out, so I think he'll be plenty happy at that power level. At that boost and power level, it is a complete waste of money to drop $1200 into building the engine, because it will run fine as is. How do I know this? Because I'm running 7 psi on a stock KA with 189,000 miles on the stock, never rebuilt engine. Guess what? It runs just fine.
Sorry, I don't mean to be so rude. I just get tired of people giving out advice based on their opinion, wich is based on some thing that they read on the internet. Personally, I never give out advice unless I have experience with the problem. Not internet experience, or something I read, but real, actual, get my hands dirty experience.
Thanks for listening.