Post by
C-Kwik »
https://forums.nicoclub.com/c-kwik-u426.html
Mon Jun 28, 2004 8:53 am
I was at work during my last post so I didn't watch it again there. After staring at it a couple of minutes, I think there was definitely a period of transition in there. slw240sx will probably have to be our eyes and ears to fill in some of the details. Particularly about the car waiting to turn left. I can't see if there is a separate left turn signal there or not. The oncoming cars appear to be slowing down fairly early on. It's hard to say when the red car starts slowing down with any real certainty. As it passes the 1st tree on it's right just after the 1 second mark of the video is crossed, the red car's front end may have started dipping indicating it may have hit it's brakes at that point. But it's rather unclear seeing as how it is so small. I'm also speculating that if the car waiting to make a left has a separate left turn light, he may have had to wait until after the cross traffic gets the right of way.
This would indicate that there was at least 5 seconds between the time the red car started braking and the time of the impact(6 second mark). It is possible there was more time. I'd expect the yellow light to be on for anywhere between 3-5 seconds. But the light may have been yellow slightly longer as reaction time for hitting the brakes(sight to braking) is about 0.75 seconds. So potentially at the least, the light was yellow almost 4-6 seconds before the impact. Another thing to throw in is that fom when one light turns red until the next light turns green, there is usually about a 1 second delay.
So it's a little difficult to say the SUV had a green yet. And I'd say the PT definitely did not have a green light anymore. It had to be either red or yellow.
The SUV appears to have been in the left lane. Chances are both of them saw each other after it was too late, but tried to make an attempt to miss each other. You can see the PT hit it's brakes and move slightly left before the impact. I'd expect the SUV probably hit the brakes ans swerved right. The SUV hits the pedestrian while is in the right lane. The SUV appears to go through the right lane pretty square but ultimately ends up closer to the curb when it comes to rest. This indicates the SUV was moving at an angle to the right after the impact.
The only explanation about the pedestrian is that he perhaps enetered the intersection late so he was still walking through as the light turned red.
The SUV is carrying quite a bit of speed for someone who just got a green light. So he was definitely not stopped at the intersection. The question in my mind is did he time the light, or perhaps was speeding and when the light turned green, got on the gas, or at worst, had no intention of stopping at any light.
There appears to be plenty of witnesses(I really do hope they stopped to give their info), so they can probably fill in a lot of details. But I do see potential for this being a comparative liability case where each party shares some responsibility. But there are definitely a lot of blanks to be filled in. I would love to handle the liability portion of a claim like this.
Some side notes. This is a really good example for all three parties. First, pay attention and if you have a yellow, and you can stop, then stop. Second, if you're light turns green as you approach an intersection, don't immediately speed up. Look both ways as you enter the intersection. Especially if there is a car stopped at the intersection in the lane next to you. Lastly, if you are a pedestrian, use the crosswalk button and only go if you see the walk sign. Also be aware as a pedestrian when you are a pedestrian. Even if you are not at fault for an impact as a pedestrian, generally the car will win when you look at the big picture. The transition period of light phases in an intersection is one of the most dangerous times to be in an intersection.