Thanks for the State Farm suggestion!
I've actually been getting quotes all afternoon, and State Farm is definitely one of the best I've gotten.
Here's how it's looking:
Allstare 105/month
Ameriprise 111
Amica 119
eSurance 113
Farmers 130
GEICO 129
Progressive 131
State Farm 99
Travelers 102
As you can see, State Farm is actually the cheapest quote I've found. Well, cheapest from a reliable company. I found a smaller guy,
http://www.4autoinsurancequote.com , who quoted me at $62, but, that's obviously too good to be true. They seem a little sketchy anyways.
http://www.statefarm.com seems to be the best option for me at the moment. The 6 month policy is less than $600, which is amazing.