Chaotic_Warlord wrote:Something told me that Applebonker would be one of the first people to post in this thread... Don't know why I thought that.
If I didn't go out to lunch, I would have beat him
AppleBonker wrote:Interesting article, and a couple of those songs are great test songs, IMO. The only problem I have with this is that some of the songs aren't entirely familiar to me. I've always thought that the best test tracks for a system are those you are intimately familiar with. If you don't know what nuances to look for, it wont mean a damn thing if they are clearly audible or not. For that reason, I don't think any two reviewers should ever use the same tracks (unless they have identical taste in music which is highly unlikely).
+1. As Adam said, if you don't know what to listen for, how are you going to know what it should sound like, or have any other reference to what the song sounds like? It's like listening to a Bose system at Best Buy, completely separate from everything else - it sounds good because someone told you it sounds good, not because you have any other frame of reference.
Also, in terms of Dynamic range...some of those songs are severly limiting. I want to hear a song that can fulfil a large chunk of the audible spectrum at once - THAT'S a real measure of how good a system really is, not if someone's voice sounds natural and "centered in front of me." Boom Boom Pow? Great, lets hear how well the bass works.
Give me a song like Sacred Worlds or Wheel of Time by Blind Guardian (first songs that came to my mind - listening to the new CD now) that infuses both melodic orchestral parts with powerful, chugging guitars, booming double bass drums, and multi-octave choral singing to really see how well your system can respond.