That is somewhat true. The G section is also growing and we are trying to segment things out somewhat to allow for that growth.Q451990 wrote:My impression of the G forum is that most everything ends up in their general discussion forum anyhow, since that's where it will get noticed.
Heath
Compared to a year or three ago - yes - much less traffic. Some of it was very noticable right after the transition to the new software and is getting better now. My big concern is that we'll get to a point where using the correct forum for a question about, for example, a drive shaft issue, would get someone very few answers vs. if it was posted in a general Q45 forum. So then the member either doesn't get an answer, or double posts, or starts posting in the wrong forum. No answer is bad, and the other two can result in people sniping about double posting, etc. I think your point about the sections specializing in Audio, Detailing, etc. being dead helps illustrate what can happen when we try to segment things out too much.Paul Wall wrote:Q traffic at a decline? You should see the Nissan Quest, detailing, Audio and security sections.
Paul, you've tried really hard to fit to in in the Q section from your arrival here, and done some nice work for the community. I think you might be a bit overzealous in your aspirations for content migration in the Q section though, just a ton of work when most people (hopefully) would search, or post prior to navigating through a newly developed topic tree. Nevermind the constant time involved for mods to move posts from one section to another. Cost vs. benefit...Paul Wall wrote:And like I said all that needs to be done is me made part of the NICO staff and I will do all I can to make the Q section a better place. And as far as I know NICO staff aren't paid and I don't want anything but to see the Q section of NICO and the actual car live on for many years to come. I will email Greg a link to this topic in case he doesn't see it though.
2 of the 4 Admins don't want this so this won't happen, I can tell.MinisterofDOOM wrote:I'll offer a little input:
As someone who has seen both sides of both setups, I'd say you really need a very busy forum to actually benefit from separate subsections.
If traffic is too low, subforums can actually be a bad thing. As posting is "thinned" across multiple subforums, some will go ignored over time and, eventually, you'll end up with the "general" section being used for everything. As noted above, the G forum gets a lot of traffic and is growing (and is likely to become the busiest forum over the next few years, potentially even supplanting the 240 forums). The Q forum has a small but dedicated group of participants, but isn't likely to get much bigger (unless Infiniti were to bring the model back, and even then most of the potential buyers for the car a new Q would likely be probably aren't the forum-dwelling type).
So, based on that, my view is that the Q forum is left consolidated. That's certainly not an official position, just my opinion.
Infiniti Help and Fresh Alloy are the only other Q45 forums that I know of. But I can say for sure NICO is far better than Infiniti Help. But I am rarely at Fresh Alloy so I can't comment there. And the F50 Q45 is still somewhat new so it can only get better as far as Forum help goes.djwarner wrote:An F50 section would probably qualify for the world's thinnest books.
The reason Unknown007 is no longer here is because he destroyed his Q BY NOT LISTENING to the boatloads of advice he was given- thats right, he DESTROYED his car.....junk,gone, in the boneyard. Many other recent Q owners we have seen join here have been teenagers and poor people who bought their Q for next to nothing and crapped their pants when the first repair bill came in ......they are no longer active members because they are no longer able to afford to keep their old q on road.....off to junkyard or next sucker to gets sucked in by V8 with pretty paint for a few hundred bucks asking price....never thinking the ongoing expense to keep on road.Sad to say but the 90-96Q is becoming extinct from the roads.......afterall the newest ones{1996} are now 15 years old and who other than the poor or foolish purchases 15-21 year old high mile ancient lux cars?????NightRiderQ45 wrote:Great post Wes, I agree completely especially with the xxx post requirement. If we were to break the Q section into sub forums, we might as well kiss the Q section good bye. If you think about it, currently it's just the same members 10 members max posting. A lot of the younger guys were ran away by some of the older members and now this forum is honestly boring now. E.g. even though Unknown007 was a young member, I actually enjoyed reading his posts about his car. He was really trying to learn about his G50, but he got bashed so badly by older members, he doesn't post here anymore. You will have new members that sign up just to get their question answered and then you won't hear from them anymore. I don't have a lot of posts myself, but I know a lot about our Q's and can help most new members with their questions. I only post if I have a question or if I can help someone else. I don't do general chat so my posts are low. I'm sorry but high post count doesn't mean much either. If we were to go to the xxx post requirement, I would be ousted to the newbie section when I'm actually not.
Honestly, I like the way the site is now because if you were to break it up into sub forums, the traffic to either forum would be awfully slow.
Well thats half true because there was a local guy (Bgerner?) I am not sure of the spelling on his name but he did have a 1995 Q45a in a silver color with the rare 1990-1992 Infiniti Q45 interior colors (Yes it was a dark mocha interior). He only came here to get the car running great and he left. It all depends on the person and there time and love for there vehicle.qship96 wrote:The reason Unknown007 is no longer here is because he destroyed his Q BY NOT LISTENING to the boatloads of advice he was given- thats right, he DESTROYED his car.....junk,gone, in the boneyard. Many other recent Q owners we have seen join here have been teenagers and poor people who bought their Q for next to nothing and crapped their pants when the first repair bill came in ......they are no longer active members because they are no longer able to afford to keep their old q on road.....off to junkyard or next sucker to gets sucked in by V8 with pretty paint for a few hundred bucks asking price....never thinking the ongoing expense to keep on road.Sad to say but the 90-96Q is becoming extinct from the roads.......afterall the newest ones{1996} are now 15 years old and who other than the poor or foolish purchases 15-21 year old high mile ancient lux cars?????NightRiderQ45 wrote:Great post Wes, I agree completely especially with the xxx post requirement. If we were to break the Q section into sub forums, we might as well kiss the Q section good bye. If you think about it, currently it's just the same members 10 members max posting. A lot of the younger guys were ran away by some of the older members and now this forum is honestly boring now. E.g. even though Unknown007 was a young member, I actually enjoyed reading his posts about his car. He was really trying to learn about his G50, but he got bashed so badly by older members, he doesn't post here anymore. You will have new members that sign up just to get their question answered and then you won't hear from them anymore. I don't have a lot of posts myself, but I know a lot about our Q's and can help most new members with their questions. I only post if I have a question or if I can help someone else. I don't do general chat so my posts are low. I'm sorry but high post count doesn't mean much either. If we were to go to the xxx post requirement, I would be ousted to the newbie section when I'm actually not.
Honestly, I like the way the site is now because if you were to break it up into sub forums, the traffic to either forum would be awfully slow.
Isn't the reason Unknown was being towed was because his car was a little low (1.5 " clearance IIRC) and he punctured his oil pan? His Q falling off the tow truck was the best thing that ever happened to him. He got a least a couple grand for a car that would have been hard to sell for more than $500, punctured oil pan or not, and ended up with a 240sx and some cash in his pocket. I think he's happy now.Paul Wall wrote:Berner did somewhat destroy his car but he did the damn best he could by himself and he learned from that car and became a better person for it. The car falling off the tow truck was the final nail in the coffin because the car ran before that, But it had some HLA tick (Due to the HLA's bleeding down after a while?).qship96 wrote:.......The reason Unknown007 is no longer here is because he destroyed his Q BY NOT LISTENING to the boatloads of advice he was given- thats right, he DESTROYED his car.....junk,gone, in the boneyard......
To be fair to those members, it's not always a case of pants-crapping so much as a sensible acceptance that these aged cars just aren't worth much anymore. I'm sure many of those members purchased the car with the intent of driving it until it needed replacing, but trying to make every dollar go as far as it could. There's nothing wrong with that, if that's all you want out of the car.qship96 wrote:Many other recent Q owners we have seen join here have been teenagers and poor people who bought their Q for next to nothing and crapped their pants when the first repair bill came in ...
LOL!! Oh wow! I didn't know he destroyed his car!! I guess I missed that thread. The last I read he was trying to get something sandblasted at his school. Ok, my fault then...but it is good to listen to the experienced members. I had a K&N in my car when I first joined the site. I took it out after seeing how dirty my TB was after I cleaned it and researched that a simple paper filter was much better than the oiled filter. Other than the sound the K&N created, it wasn't worth it.qship96 wrote:The reason Unknown007 is no longer here is because he destroyed his Q BY NOT LISTENING to the boatloads of advice he was given- thats right, he DESTROYED his car.....junk,gone, in the boneyard. Many other recent Q owners we have seen join here have been teenagers and poor people who bought their Q for next to nothing and crapped their pants when the first repair bill came in ......they are no longer active members because they are no longer able to afford to keep their old q on road.....off to junkyard or next sucker to gets sucked in by V8 with pretty paint for a few hundred bucks asking price....never thinking the ongoing expense to keep on road.Sad to say but the 90-96Q is becoming extinct from the roads.......afterall the newest ones{1996} are now 15 years old and who other than the poor or foolish purchases 15-21 year old high mile ancient lux cars?????NightRiderQ45 wrote:Great post Wes, I agree completely especially with the xxx post requirement. If we were to break the Q section into sub forums, we might as well kiss the Q section good bye. If you think about it, currently it's just the same members 10 members max posting. A lot of the younger guys were ran away by some of the older members and now this forum is honestly boring now. E.g. even though Unknown007 was a young member, I actually enjoyed reading his posts about his car. He was really trying to learn about his G50, but he got bashed so badly by older members, he doesn't post here anymore. You will have new members that sign up just to get their question answered and then you won't hear from them anymore. I don't have a lot of posts myself, but I know a lot about our Q's and can help most new members with their questions. I only post if I have a question or if I can help someone else. I don't do general chat so my posts are low. I'm sorry but high post count doesn't mean much either. If we were to go to the xxx post requirement, I would be ousted to the newbie section when I'm actually not.
Honestly, I like the way the site is now because if you were to break it up into sub forums, the traffic to either forum would be awfully slow.
Seriously? APPRECiation vs DEPRECiation.Paul Wall wrote:Sure car's are a waste of money to some but so is a house in my option. A car is a like a mini house and if maintained properly it can last indefinitely, same with a house. Except some choose to believe a house is better because of so and so reason.
Well I get a call from him about a year ago and he says he wants a Q45 transmission from a 1990-1993. I say I have one but the car was towed with the rear wheels on the ground and he says "I don't care its fine"I told him shipping will be a lot. He says "Thats fine I have shipped many of these in my day and I have a transmission box I will send you to make it easier". I say just to clarify "I have never shipped anything this big and I want to be sure you will buy it, He says "I will buy it". So I go down to the yard where my friend has it at and he tells me he wants $35 to take the car down and pull the engine out. I say fine, you got to lose some to wins some. I tell Johnny I pulled out the transmission but it weighs a bit (Like with all automatics). He says "the transmission case my not work then for some reason". So I go out and get estimates to ship the transmission between $300-$400 and he "says wow thats a lot". I say well it is what it is and I only wanted $150 I think for the transmission maybe less. I would have worked with the guy but its the $35 fee to pull it out that was hurting me.NightRiderQ45 wrote:Hey Paul, why do you hate Johnny Rocket? Do you personally know him? I was wondering because if you didn't know him personally, how can you hate someone over the e-net?