you probably just had to reset your ECU, and then let the ECU get "used" to the new cat. My CEL light came on because I put a K&N Filter. I know, most people would say wtf? why would it come on with a K&N Filter? Well, it did, reset the ECU, then drove it fine.

Word of advice: Always reset your ecu (unplug battery for a few hours, or from the ECU itself) when you install something new (not oil or fuel filters, but like a new fuel pump, and anything that increases the flow of anything, like say your cat back, for instance.)