Post by
MinisterofDOOM »
https://forums.nicoclub.com/ministerofdoom-u16506.html
Mon Feb 08, 2010 9:52 pm
System Shock 2 was one of Ken Levine/Irrational's prior games, and is commonly regarded as one of the (or THE, depending on who you ask) greatests game ever made. It was released back in 99, and Bioshock was basically conceived as a spiritual successor to SS2. It was a hybrid RTS/RPG like Bioshock, but the RPG elements were MUCH deeper and the shooter elements were also deeper and more fleshed out. There were multiple classes and deeper character development. The story was good and continued from SS1 (though the game and story stood well on their own, meaning you weren't lost if you didn't play SS1). The villain, SHODAN (a rogue AI) is commonly regarded as one of the greatest and most interesting villains in all of videogame history.
If you're interested, there's a very long (but absolutely brilliant) article about why SHODAN is so great here. Reading it really brings back a lot of the feelings of playing SS2 for the first time. It also offers a pretty good synopsis of the SS1/SS2 story arc and the gameplay mechanics that combine with that story arc to produce Digital Awesome.
Basically, SS2 set a VERY VERY high bar, so when Irrational stated that Bioshock was to be a spiritual successor to System Shock 2, they set the expectations for Bioshock extremely high as well. The game didn't meet those expectations. Most SS2 fans were highly disappointed by Bioshock, while those who didn't have those high expectations liked it a lot.
I still liked Bioshock, but I would have preferred something with SS2's depth of gameplay to match the good story.
FWIW, reviews I've read of Bioshock 2 have been very positive, but they do say the story and characters fail to live up to those of the first game. And actually, reviews are even saying the multiplayer is quite decent. It has a progression system that has you building your Adam powers which does help it feel a little more like the main game. One neat aspect of the multiplayer mode is that it takes place in pre-rebellion Rapture, when everything is not yet ruined.