Post by
elwesso »
https://forums.nicoclub.com/elwesso-u5248.html
Sun Sep 30, 2007 12:38 pm
After reading clyons thread about the G35, it always brings into my head what brings people to buying a Q45, and actually keeping it and restoring it.
If you are one of the many people that bought a G50 because it was cheap, and barely maintain it, this does NOT pertain to you. If all your rubber components (engine and suspension), fluids, brakes, etc are not brand new or recently replaced............... basically, if you dont know WHEN it was done, this does not apply to you.
I hate to sound like this, but this almost doesnt apply to any other Q45 chassis other than the G50. Y33's were a lot simpler, and are newer therefore requiring less maintenance now, but theyre catching up. F50s are still babies, so they still got a good 4-5 years before they start needing a major overhaul.
This applies to the ELITE CLASS of Q45 owners, who bought them, cheap or not, and have sunk endless time and money into them to make them some of the best performing cars on the road in its class...
The point of this thread is to raise the question: Is owing a Q45 with the purpose to restore it an effort in futility, or is it actually a smart move in acquiring autmotive excellence?
It seems that I've had a better experience with my Q than most others have.. Ive had no failures (other than the engine in my 1st Q, that doesnt count). Never had an injector go bad (knock on wood).. Just modifications, and maintenance.
ANYWAYMy justification for this is as follows. Lets say i have $15,000 to spend on a car.... What can I get for that price range, in a sporty but luxury sedan with roughly 300 HP?
Cadillac STSInfiniti Q45BMW 5 Series, maybe an older M5Mercedes E ClassAudi A6Jaguar XJ8 or XJR*let me know if Im missing anything*
If you look at intial cost, the Q45 and the STS are probably the lowest on there, mainly because they are the oldest out fo the bunch.
If you care about driving, who really wants FWD? That takes out the STS, not to mention the headache that is the northstar. the 4.0 Jag isnt a bad choice, but will cost 2x as much as a G50. The BMW is also a good choice, and the available manual trans is tempting! The mercedes and audi are probably too troublesome to own, meaning that you can have ridiculous problems even after you replace things. mainly im talking about electrical issues. Q45s have very few electrical issues that are seemingly "unsolvable".
Basically, there arent very many cars out there that will love you back if you love them. The G50 is an ultra reliable car, once you have new components and keep them nice by maintaining them, things DONT BREAK. Not to mention, it probably has some of the cheapest parts out fo that list, outside of the STS.
I can watch ebay for a week, pick out a clean cosmetic Q for under 5 grand ALL DAY... Lets assume the car is a great looking parts car, so what would it cost to bring it back to OEM (since we're assuming we have to replace everything).
This is just parts.$1500 for a new JDM motor$2000 for a new trans from Joe$300 for new brakes$800 for new wheels and tires (since you cant get good tires in 15 anymore)$2000 to rehab the suspension and other rubber components (add 1500 if its an active)$3000 for other misc stuff you didnt see coming.$500 for basic essential mods like ECU, FSTB, active rear bar, etc
so around 10 grand in parts, maybe most of that $3000 is in labor, who knows. I dont know if you can get just a TRANSMISSION for any of those other cars under 4 grand, brand new from the factory...
Obviously, this is buying brand new parts off the shelf and going crazy, you can clearly do a lot better. Most decently maintained VH45s and RE4R03A's will not need replaced, just some TLC assuming they work from the get go. its amazing how well these transmissions last with just fluid changes. Ive heard numerous cases of transmissions slipping and being on their death bed and end up being rock solid after a double trans flush. A friend of mine from atlanta has 280k on his original 1994 transmission with NO EXTERNAL cooler. Sure its a little sluggish, but it works still, and as far as i know worked nearly as new until 250k miles.
SO, what do you end up with? In my opinion, you end up with a car that will require not much more maintenance over the next 100k miles than a honda civic or toyota camry, will hang with nearly any car on the highway (wont necessarily beat everything, but wont be embarrassed), and a car that you can drive until and not feel like stopping until it runs out of gas. All of this for under $15 grand.
Its a shame that the initial cost puts these cars in that hands of people that either cant handle them or cant afford them. Now if we start talking about ACTIVE Q45's, then we're in a whole different ballpark and that car is probably unbeatable.
Sorry for the long post, but I like to hear these peoples comments. The ONLY OTHER car I woudl get rid of my Q for is a BMW M5, regardless of year. I cant think of any other car I'd rather have to replace my Q.