Some guy? [you didn't check his credentials]........You would be surprised that 70% of the AC shops are hacks, not cause they want to be but just to compete with the really bad ones, who seem to offer low cost repairs.
"PAG or POE is a touchy debate. Manufacturers use PAG in new systems because PAG is technically a better lubricant than POE oils. The two major problems with PAG is are hydroscopity (it absorbs alot of moisture) and it cannot tolerate chlorine. Chlorine is not a problem in new squeaky clean systems but it is a problem in retrofitted system. Too much chlorine can break down a pag oil. POE oils are not as hydroscopic as PAG's but in contrast they do not lubricate as well. At least that was the thinking years ago when the whole retrofit thing started. Modern day oils are far better then they were years ago and both PAG's and POE's are more tolerant.
In your situation the person who sold you the compressor is going by what the manufacturer recommends to warrenty the compressor and/or assuming it is going into a genuine 134a system. The warrenty on the compressor will not be voided by using a POE oil. Most warrenties would be voided if you used a blend refrigerant.
The viscocity between the two oils is different PAG 46 is well 46 and POE's are around 100 to 150. The viscocity of the oil is not a factor because the properties of the two oils are different but they both are capable of lubricating the compressor.
Decision time, ask 10 different people and you will get different answers, this is my logic. PAG oils are best used in new 96' or later systems that came from the factory with PAG oils. POE oils are best used in r12 system that were retrofitted to 134a. Good quality POE oils like the BVA100 are just as capable as PAG oils and do not absorb as much moisture. Moisture is critical and as a DIY'r you need access to a good mechanical vacuum pump to remove it. Using a venturi pump or having an AC shop evac the system for 30 minutes will leave some behind so the POE can tolerate these residuals better than PAG's.
This is what I would do, but remember this is my opinion. You said the compressor was not installed, that is good. Drain the compressor on a bench by turning it upside down and turning the hub and draining the oil into a measuring cup. You will not get it all out. Then pour some ester oil into the compressor and again turn the hub to remove it. If you have the time let it sit and let gravity remove the rest. Then reassemble the system and distribute the oil, 2oz in the condenser, 2oz in the evaporator, and the remainder in the compressor. Use a good quality POE like the BVA100 sold on ackits.com.
Try to keep the time the oil is exposed to air at a minimum, remember it absorbs moisture like a sponge. Having a little extra oil in the system is OK but I would not exceed 2oz over the recommended oil level."
http://www.aircondition.com/wwwboard/ht ... com/forum/