st3 wrote:How do those work on the M? I liked those tires on my old car and have been thinking about putting them on my M because I hate the Michelin's so much.
The Goodyear Eagle F1 GS/D3 is an excellent tire (scores 10 out of 10) for wet conditions - on par with my reference: the Firestone Firehawk SZ50EP for this, and a very good tire for other stuff scores (8-9 out of 10).
Not exceptionally quiet (7/10), but decent enough that I am not concerned about that. Dry road stickiness is very good (8/10), but not quite on par with the Firehawk SZ50EP (9+/10).
My experience with the Goodyears on my wife's car (in a different 205/55-16 89V size) is that they require frequent rebalancing (every 3k miles or so.) I am hoping that the new 100W rating of the 245/45-18 size (previous was 96Y, and may still be available) means that the tire is stronger and will not require re-balancing as much.
I have noticed one other interesting thing though. These 100W tires have stiffer sidewalls than the Bridgestone Turanza ER33 (235/45-18 94W) that came OEM on the M. When driving at 9/10 (which I sometimes do on curvy roads), the suspension seems to be a bit more disconcerted with the stiffer sidewall ... the car is a bit more "hoppy" on bumps in curves.
I have had to slow down by about 5% on some roads (that I drive a lot and am very familiar with) to get the same degree of surefootedness that I had with the softer sidewall tires.
So, when these wear out, I am going to try some softer sidewalls (probably in a 95 or 96 load index) like the Avon Tech 550 or the Michelin Pilot Sport A/S to see if I can restore the handling in extreme situations. I think the suspension was more geared for the 94 load index tires that came as OEM.
Of course, I must emphasize that I am talking about some extreme situations in this regard! There is a stretch of curvy mountain road near my house that has a speed limit of 45mph that I could easily take at 90+ mph on the SZ50EP (on my Q45) and at 85+ mph on the Turanza ER33 (on my M45) , that I am now taking at 80+ on the Eagle F1 GS/D3.
FWIW, most people do not drive this section of road any faster than 65mph or so. I have kept up with Porsche Turbo 911's on this twisty road with ease.
BTW, I truly wish that the Firestone Firehawk SZ50EP were still made ... those were the best tires I have ever used ... in 30+ years of driving! The new Firestone Firehawk Wide Oval may be similar, but it is not yet made in an appropriate 18" width (like a 235/45 or 245/45) that I can try out.
I do think that people with 17x7.5 or 17x8 wheels ought to try the 245/45-17 Wide Ovals and see how they work out.
Z