Post by
Jacko3 »
https://forums.nicoclub.com/jacko3-u85814.html
Tue Jan 29, 2008 5:16 am
It seems like some 03 - 04 G-35s had transmission problems and some 05 - 07 had oil consumption problems. I can't wrap my mind around such anomalies for the VQ engine.
I really don't think the problem is the clutch or the transmission itself in the 03 - 04 engines. There is something about the way the VQ engine in a G-35 transfers power to its gearbox, and the corresponding interaction of the gearbox with the engine, that is causing this problem.
I can say this with confidence because I had a new revised VQ engine installed in my car due to oil consumption. My car is a 2007 G-35 Coupe. The new engine has more torque and more power, and it does not leak any oil at all, except for a quarter of a quart during break in.
In my old engine, I could feel that my transmission was not totally connected to the car. I was always apprehensive about my transmission at 5500 RPMS or more. It seemed that the transmission was way more powerful than what the engine could put out. Engine could not produce enough power due to whatever was causing its oil consumption. Can you beleive that on many occassions i had actually floored the pedal to the floor and yet the car seemed like it was struggling to make power? So, I knew that at some point, if nothing was done, the transmission would start having problems as a result of the way the engine responded to the transmission.
So, here I am today with a new revised VQ engine. After it was installed, and I drove off the dealership, the engine felt perfect and well adjusted to the transmission. In fact, the new revised VQ engine replacement for those with oil consupmtion issues is so torqy that now I worry that I would use up my clutch much faster than anticipated. I am saving for a clutch now because the torque of the new engine is a lot like a V-8, especially when you hit 3,000RPM while giving the car some gas. It pins you to the seat. I also can't seem to drive in the rain or with my VDC on anymore, even with the superb Bridgestone Potenza RE050 tires. The engine causes the tires to spin more often than I want. Again, a result of the the torque issue. Old engine never did this. As for the transmission, it feels very happy and friendly with the new engine. It is now more well behaved. Even my mechanic noticed this difference and he commented on it.
Because of the amount of torque, the Pennzoil blend they used in the car was adding to the torque, and made the engine feel like the pressure in the cylinders was very high. In fact, with Pennzoil blend, I get all the low end torque at about 2,500 RPM, but then, I get a lot less high end power. So, I switched oil brands to Catrol Synblend, which has freed up the engine a little bit and has raised the torque bar to 3,000RPM, while allowing me more high end power. Castrol Synblend even after 1,000 miles, looks clean and unused. Again, i am on the fence with full synthetic given the impressive performance of Castrol Syn blend. I suspect Castrol is working extra hard and putting out excellent oil in order to steal market share from its biggest synthetic and belnd competitor---Mobil
All I am saying here is that I have now come to appreciate why an engine must match its transmission perfectly. I may be wrong but it seems an engine with insuffficient power matched against its transmission can destroy a transmission over time just as an engine with excessive power over what the transmission can handle. I am a witness to this. It is for this reason that i have always had second thoughts about superchargers and twin turbos--their negative effect on my transmission, given my experiences so far, even without these modifcations. To thie end, I thin the rotuine modifications for our cars, such as cat-back exhaust, intakes, headers, spacers, plenums and the likes, are sufficient and okay for our transmission and engines. if you want to do more with a VQ engine, I suggest you change some engine internals and perhaps order a more fortified transmission if you intend to keep the car for a long time.
The 03-04 Coupes with 280 Horses may have been slightly less powered than the capacity of their transmission. Whatever changes infinity made to their transmission, must have been designed to account for the less horsepower. And I am sure it was a small change or design flaw, nothing significant. For the 05-07 engines with oil consumption issues, major changes may have been undertaken in the internal engine componentrs. I heard valve guides, springs, pistons, etc where replaced inside the engine. I am not sure. Whatever they did, it worked.