Post by
MovieMaestro10 »
https://forums.nicoclub.com/moviemaestro10-u262915.html
Mon May 02, 2016 7:11 pm
My two cents on the three Q45 generations, as someone whose dad owned a 1st gen, who recently bought a 2nd gen, and who test drove several 3rd gens. (Curious if you all agree)
1st Gen- The enthusiast special. I remember this car being much faster than my 2nd gen. Avant-garde looks inside and out, less of a traditional luxury feel. It felt special, from the hefty key to the font on the instruments. I do recall it having a "tinny" feel though, door slams rang hollow and lots of cheap plastic inside (as most cars of the era had). Best visibility from inside the car of the generations.
Nearly impossible to find a good one for a good price anymore, parts seem to be getting dear, you have to deal with OBD1 in most years. I remember my dad eventually sold it for how difficult it was to keep up even then.
Music style: Alternative rock
2nd Gen- The "traditional luxury on a budget" special. Emphasis shifted from performance to greater comfort...More leather, softer materials, chrome, wood, and rear seat space. I find its the most pleasant Q45 to sit in...Immediately feels familiar, if generic. I think the styling has aged the best, maybe because it was the most conservative. It was nicely sharp edged and crisp, like a well tailored suit, when other cars of the era were round soap bars. Best door handles of ANY car!
Feels much more substantial than 1st gen in every way, doors close with a solid thump, but also slower, but still no slouch. The simplest of all the Q's, supposedly the most reliable (though coil packs and steering system issues are common). Parts are plentiful, and these cars sold well and are not hard to find plenty of good ones still out there.
Music style: Smooth jazz
3rd Gen- The boys with toys special. So many gadgets, esp in the Premium packaged cars! Ovoid styling isn't for everyone. Those headlights are neat but are known to have constant ballast issues. I test drove three cars of this gen...All of them seemed to have a dozen electronics that weren't working. The interior controls and gadgets take some time to figure out, but when sorted they're pretty neat.
Much faster car...Terrific engine sound. The safest in a crash too. They didn't sell many of these, so hard to find a well-sorted example, and parts are still pretty dear.
Music style: Techno/EDM
They each have their pluses and minuses. I'm on a budget, and prefer driving my car to working on it, and considering I can't go too fast in LA traffic anyways, the second gen an easy choice for me.
I also drove an LS400 of the same vintage- In many ways a better car, but bland styling inside and out. An equivalent LS400 cost 2k more than a Q45 when I was looking. And trying to find one that didn't need a timing belt change was impossible (Q45 has good old timing chain!)
Do you all agree?