Larz wrote:The difference between 19 or 20 wheels is mostly the eye of the beholder.
I agree. Less sidewall does technically make for more road-feel and control but is probably negligible between 19 and 20. 18 to 20 is a significant jump though and should be very apparent.
Larz wrote:The only difference with adding 20's is that you probably need to do suspension work to lower the car. I didn't need to lower the car or add spacers.
Not sure what you mean by suspension work but other then springs or adjustable coilovers you don't
need do anything else for 19's or 20's. You also don't
need to lower the car for 19's or 20's so I assume you mean cosmetically. And the need for spacers is based on wheel offset, clearance needs, and (like lowering) cosmetic preferences, not wheel diameter.
Although the top fender gap with factory 18's and 20's does not stand out as much as it does with aftermarket 20's it still very noticeable (I look at the 18's gap everyday
). For me it becomes especially obvious when aftermarket wheels of any size are used. Even with the small increase to 19's I think this gap would be too much for me personally. Can't tell though since all the pictures in your tread are taken from very close and with this gap cropped out.
Back to the OP's question, like suggested above I think if lowering is not being considered the factory 20's would be perfect.