I think the gas cap could turn this light on.
Is it screwed in tightly?
I know you said it was not the gas cap but you also said the light was off so no test results were read.
When I first purchased mine I thought I screwed the gas cap on tightly too. But, my light came on around 500 then again at 1500. Everytime after that I held the plastic gas cap retainer so it would not turn when I turned the cap and make it click 4 or 5 times.
Never ever came back on and I am at 67k. So, since it is off just keep this in mind.
Also even after making sure my cap was tight the light remained on for 4-7 days each time.