Post by
AG-M35 »
https://forums.nicoclub.com/ag-m35-u50500.html
Mon Oct 01, 2007 8:44 am
Well, Andrew, Wow! Thanks for your perspective, but here are a few bits you might want to think about...First, most all transmissions HAVE a filter and it's there for a very good reason. It doesn't take "air" in the transmission to have a particle from normal wear and tear, drain into the pan. If one bit of grit or clutch facing gets into the valve body, it would wreak havoc on the mechanism and you'd be sidelined in quick order. Not having a filter on such an expensive item, is definitely not good design and you can take that to the bank. It's just another form of the anti-consumer animus that pervades most auto manufacturers these days. Your idea about a syrupy sludge forming in the bottom of the pan is gibberish. Transmission fluid is highly detergent and will hold normal dirt and other particles in suspension, supposedly, to be FILTERED before entering the pickup and getting cycled again. Forcing grit through your transmission will only cause faster wear and tear. Further, transmission fluid contains additives, which inhibit wear and provide superior lubrication. These additives get used up over a period of time and that period is much less than the 30K miles, used as a suggested replacement point. So, not changing it more often, will only exacerbate any problems you may have already generated by following their guidelines. Your recommendation about taking it to the dealer would be the only way to get it done, as specified, in the manual. However, their change interval, isn't in your best interest, moreso theirs. You can, of course, get it changed more often ($$$$). Trusting your $50K car to a place like AAMCO is, probably, the utmost in poor judgement. If you believe you should not check and change your fluid(s) more often than a dealer tells you, I have a bridge you might be interested in. This leads to another point of interest that you might notice on your car. The suspension is real beefy, the brakes are huge, the radiator is a decent size. The engine, which is the most expensive component, is a wonder and certainly does a lot for the demands put on it but have you ever noticed the size of the oil filter. All that technology is protected by something, the size of a can of tomato paste. I suppose you wouldn't dare think of changing your engine oil more often than every 7500 miles...
Best wishes ...(really)