hi guys. thanks for your reply. first of all, after a bunch of haggling, I did get them replaced by the warranty company. I provided a bunch of documents leading upto the time I bought the warranty that offered a strong case against pre-existing condition. Our state inspection for example, includes an inspection of the motormounts. The examiner is supposed to reject for failed mounts, and recommend replacement is ANY damage/wear is visible. I had it inspected 5k before warranty purchase so, there was little for them to stand on. As far as why they failed? I have no idea. Ive had the car since new, and I (like most of you im sure) baby it. I do all regular maint. myself, and have the dealer do everything else. Its never been raced, or driven REALLY hard. I have however had a LOT of things need replacement, such as: exhaust manifold, power steering pump, ENTIRE steering assembly, lower front control arms, sway bar links, ECM, drivers seat tracks, gauge cluster (for fuel gauge), front left strut, and some other things I cant remember. Despite all that, I love the car and will drive it until my wife wrecks it.

I did see the 2 mounts that were replaced, and they were surely worn beyond use. Thanks again for your help.