Nissan Forums | Infiniti Forums NICOclub staff, History and Advertising eMail NICOclub Webmaster Advertising on NICOclub Nissan forums
 
          

Active Topics

Quick Reply  Print  Email  Subscribe RSS  Help
 Rogue Roof Rack Options
Author Post
philipa_240sx
Moderator



Online

1096 posts
'08 Rogue SL FWD - Iridium Graphite
KW Ont
6-21-2007

  Rogue Roof Rack Options


I had both a hitch and roof rack for my Altima. All of my accesories are Yakima and they are wonderfully flexible products. For the Rogue I've purchased Yakima Low Riders (Part no: 8000118). They attach directly to the factory roof rails and are far more flexible than just using the Nissan crossbars.

Pictured is the full setup with 58" cross bars, gunwale brackets and my 8' fiberglass ladder. I would not recommend the 48" cross bars, the 58" ones extend past the edges of the roof adding some protection and make it easier to load bulky items. I could easily re-space the brackets for a canoe, lumber, plywood, you name it. I also have a ski/snowboard carrier (not pictured). I believe Nissan shows many of the Yakima accessories in their brochure.




PCY

Offline

47 posts

Baton Rouge LA
2-26-2008

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (philipa_240sx)


Great find here. Loving the fact of alternatives.

What's the price? Where to get? A little help is further appreciated.

-Peter-

Ticmxman



Offline

333 posts
2008 Nissan Rogue SL 2WD Gotham Gray
Cartersville GA
10-3-2007

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (philipa_240sx)


Do you notice much wind noise with the roof rack?



Tic
philipa_240sx
Moderator



Online

1096 posts
'08 Rogue SL FWD - Iridium Graphite
KW Ont
6-21-2007

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (Ticmxman)


Yes, you do get some wind noise. I haven't driven it very far with the rack installed on the Rogue to get a good idea yet. On the Altima however, it was noisy esp. at highway speeds. I would suggest a buying a fairing from Yakima to reduce/eliminate the noise.

The Lowrider clamps are $190 MSRP, the crossbars are between $70-85 MSRP. There are many retailers:

- http://www.rackattack.com has a website as well as a few retail locations throughout Canada and the USA.

- I bought mine from a Canadian retailer: http://www.actiontrucks.com / http://www.vanandtruckworld.com

Check out Yakima's website for other retailers:

http://www.yakima.com

philipa_240sx
Moderator



Online

1096 posts
'08 Rogue SL FWD - Iridium Graphite
KW Ont
6-21-2007

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (philipa_240sx)


I really like the fact the Yakima racks can be installed & removed in minutes. Once removed, the vehicle looks stock again. I cannot stress enough the importance of getting the longer 58" crossbars (as shown) instead of the 48" units Yakima recommends. You'll also get something the factory crossbars won't give you:

- increased width for larger loads (ie. a sheet of plywood)
- ability to add other attachments. Every Yakima attachment comes with clamps for the round bars. To use the factory crissbars requires buying a set of special clamps... for convenience you would have to buy these clamps for every accessory you add.

BTW, I don't have locks on mine, but they are available. Buy them in sets of 6 or more. You will need 4 for the clamps plus 2 for accessories (ie ski carrier). It's better to buy more locks than you may need as they can be purchased keyed the same. To do add additional locks with your key code after the fact requires ordering them from Yakima directly.

cdmuile

Offline

160 posts
Nissan Rogue, Scion tC RS4.0
Des Moines Ia
12-20-2007

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (philipa_240sx)


Being a safety professional, I couldn't help but notice the extension cords in the picture. Don't think they are approved for damp or wet locations. You be careful. Want you to enjoy your beautiful Rogue for many years! Cheers.
philipa_240sx
Moderator



Online

1096 posts
'08 Rogue SL FWD - Iridium Graphite
KW Ont
6-21-2007

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (cdmuile)


Both cords are SJTW (hard service, junior, thermoplastic/rubber, weather/water resistant) CAN/CSA approved for outdoor use. I've also connected them to a GFCI protected outlet. Is there something I am missing or doing incorrectly?
Etch

Offline

110 posts
2008 Nissan Rogue SL - Phantom White
Schertz TX
12-5-2007

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (philipa_240sx)


Nice. If I didn't have a full size pickup, I'd probably consider something like that, but nothing beats having a truck and an 18' trailer. :-)
cdmuile

Offline

160 posts
Nissan Rogue, Scion tC RS4.0
Des Moines Ia
12-20-2007

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (philipa_240sx)


Good for you! The GFCI is the key here. After many years in the business, I just can't help but notice possible hazards. Maybe someday I'll get over it, but after investigating numerous electrocutions, I doubt if I will.
njr

Offline

18 posts

VT
2-10-2008

 « 


I have a Rogue with the factory installed roof rack and dealer installed crossbars, but the Thule dealer says I have to buy their rack for a roof cargo box or bike rack, because of the curved rails. Anyone have experience with putting a cargo box on the Rogue withOUT Yakima or Thule rails?

philipa_240sx
Moderator



Online

1096 posts
'08 Rogue SL FWD - Iridium Graphite
KW Ont
6-21-2007

 « Re: (njr)


I honestly haven't tried. It may be possible as the cross rails are only slightly curved. Yakima's cargo boxes are universal (they work with most crossbars). I would find a Yakima dealer and see if you can test fit one of their boxes.
Lakerfan1975

Offline

14 posts
Nissan Rogue
Colorado Springs Co
12-2-2007

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (philipa_240sx)


I purchased this same setup. I had to buy the fairing(spelling?) to quiet down the noise. I swear it sounds like I'm going to blast off into orbit if I go beyond 45 mph.
cdmuile

Offline

160 posts
Nissan Rogue, Scion tC RS4.0
Des Moines Ia
12-20-2007

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (Lakerfan1975)


Really good information. Thanks for the post.
philipa_240sx
Moderator



Online

1096 posts
'08 Rogue SL FWD - Iridium Graphite
KW Ont
6-21-2007

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (Lakerfan1975)


Quote, originally posted by Lakerfan1975 »
I purchased this same setup. I had to buy the fairing(spelling?) to quiet down the noise. I swear it sounds like I'm going to blast off into orbit if I go beyond 45 mph.

Yes, aftermarket racks are noisy esp. when unloaded. And it's not just on the Rogue. I've put them on Mazda's and other Nissan's and it's the same thing. A fairing does help a fair bit. I only use mine occasionally so I live with it.

njr

Offline

18 posts

VT
2-10-2008

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options


What is a fairing???
philipa_240sx
Moderator



Online

1096 posts
'08 Rogue SL FWD - Iridium Graphite
KW Ont
6-21-2007

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (njr)


Quote, originally posted by njr »
What is a fairing???


Image courtesy Yakima and rackattack.biz

njr

Offline

18 posts

VT
2-10-2008

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options


Thanks for the photo of the fairing.

Is this the same thing as the wind deflector for the moon roof? I was about to purchase a deflector because the wind noise with the open moon roof is considerable - even with NO cargo box or other device mounted on top. If the fairing is the same thing, how does it compare in price with the factory deflector?

ntwrkd



Offline

36 posts

Hudson Valley NY
10-12-2007

 « Re: (njr)


Quote, originally posted by njr »
I have a Rogue with the factory installed roof rack and dealer installed crossbars, but the Thule dealer says I have to buy their rack for a roof cargo box or bike rack, because of the curved rails. Anyone have experience with putting a cargo box on the Rogue withOUT Yakima or Thule rails?


http://forums.nicoclub.com/zerothread/339528

philipa_240sx
Moderator



Online

1096 posts
'08 Rogue SL FWD - Iridium Graphite
KW Ont
6-21-2007

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (njr)


Quote, originally posted by njr »
Thanks for the photo of the fairing.

Is this the same thing as the wind deflector for the moon roof? If the fairing is the same thing, how does it compare in price with the factory deflector?

The fairing pictured mounts to Yakima crossbars and will not work with factory crossbars. Since the crossbars are much further back, it would just end up covering the moonroof anyway. If moonroof noise is your concern, get the OEM deflector.

Here is photo from foedoe350Z with the complete Yakima setup with fairing:


kerrton

Offline

288 posts

Lethbridge AB
2-4-2008

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (philipa_240sx)


Philip and others with experience:

I'm considering purchasing Yakima cross bars and cargo box, and I'm concerned with the amount of noise it will generate but also curious about the implications for fuel economy - has anyone measured this effect?

I still can't get over how expensive it is to put a cargo box on my Rogue's roof, so I want to make sure that if I do spend the money I won't be dissappointed with the results afterward.

Thanks a lot guys.

philipa_240sx
Moderator



Online

1096 posts
'08 Rogue SL FWD - Iridium Graphite
KW Ont
6-21-2007

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (kerrton)


Quote, originally posted by kerrton »
Philip and others with experience:

I'm considering purchasing Yakima cross bars and cargo box, and I'm concerned with the amount of noise it will generate but also curious about the implications for fuel economy - has anyone measured this effect?

Member fodoe350Z has a good thread describing his experiences with the Yakima rack and his Kayak. His fuel economy numbers are around 22-25mpg. I would estimate this is a 1-3mpg penalty. Here is his post.

http://forums.nicoclub.com/zerothread/337785

As for noise, you will not be able to completely eliminate it. Most of the noise from the crossbars occurs when they are unloaded... it's actually quite annoying. Fortunately, once loaded, the noise is reduced to what it sounds like when you drive on a very windy day.

eric_c

Offline

26 posts

Ottawa On
5-27-2008

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (philipa_240sx)


Philip,

I'm looking at getting the same set-up as yourself, but I was wondering: with the 58" bars do you ever bang your head? They look like they stick out quite a bit.

In the summer, I'd only have them on when I need to something bulky up to the cottage so no worries, but in the winter we haul a pair of sleds back-n-forth to pull our stuff across the lake so they'd be on all the time. I'm debating whether the 48" would be less in the way?

philipa_240sx
Moderator



Online

1096 posts
'08 Rogue SL FWD - Iridium Graphite
KW Ont
6-21-2007

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (eric_c)


Quote, originally posted by eric_c »
]with the 58" bars do you ever bang your head?

Yes, I've done it a couple of times actually. I'm just very careful now.

You can get away with the shorter 48" bars, but you loose capability. Trust me, the time will come when you'll kick yourself for getting the shorter 48" bars.

kerrton

Offline

288 posts

Lethbridge AB
2-4-2008

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (philipa_240sx)


GOOD DEAL: For anyone who wants a Yakima or Thule rack for their Rogue but doesn't want to pay the high cost, there is a retailer on Ebay.com selling a high quality generic version of the feet/towers and crossbars, and all of the feedback I've gotten makes it sound really awesome. For $75 bucks I got the feet/towers, the crossbars AND the locks, instead of $300 + Canadian. Yakima/Thule is good stuff but you definately pay a premium for the name brand, and they don't even include locks which I think is so cheap and annoying.

Just search for "Yakima lowrider Thule crossroad compatible ROOF RACK". They sell these like crazy in their online store according to the sales guy, shipping to Canada is cheap and fast too!

My set arrived today, I'm going to mount them tonight and if anyone wants further info or photos just message me. The bars are silver colored so it matches my Rogue better too.

Now, I am still trying to find a reasonable deal on a roof-top cargo box for the Rogue. I want the Yakima Space Cadet or an equivalent short and wide box with a lower profile. The price tag is $500 Canadian which I think is outrageous but I may end up having to just suck it up and pay for it. There are much cheaper generic "short" boxes but they always have a really high profile and look terrible, and probably have a lot of wind resistence and flex due to the flimsy non-ABS plastic. Any suggestions are welcome!

Pescakl1

Offline

209 posts
2008 Iridium Graphite SL FWD Rogue
Montreal Quebec
5-30-2008

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (kerrton)


Quote, originally posted by kerrton »
My set arrived today, I'm going to mount them tonight and if anyone wants further info or photos just message me. The bars are silver colored so it matches my Rogue better too.

Silver cross bars, cool!!
Could you show some pics of the installation... should look good.

philipa_240sx
Moderator



Online

1096 posts
'08 Rogue SL FWD - Iridium Graphite
KW Ont
6-21-2007

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (kerrton)


Quote, originally posted by kerrton »
Yakima/Thule is good stuff but you definately pay a premium for the name brand, and they don't even include locks which I think is so cheap and annoying.

I have seen this generic version on eBay and I would like to point out some differences:

- The rails are rectangular and made of aluminum. They may fit Thule accessories, but some Yakima stuff may not work as they depend on round bars. Yakima rails are heavy duty 1" dia steel (14ga?) coated with 1/8" plastic to prevent damage to the cargo.

- The clamp system goes underneath the bar. While more secure, it may not fit some irregular crossbar designs. It also make it more time consuming to install the rack.... you have to thread the clamp under the bar each time taking care not to scratch the roof. Portions of the the clamp appear not to have any protective padding to prevent scratching.

The Yakima system has 2 curved 'jaw's that are open at the bottom. Just place on the factory rails and tighten the screw. Very fast, no fiddling, and no risk of scratching as all contact points are covered with a rubber like material.

- Yes, Kakima does not include locks. But thier locks (like the rest of the hardware) are high quality. You can also get matched sets so you only need one key.

- This is probably a good alternative for someone looking for a rack just to carry a cargo box and such. But if you need flexibility and the ability to carry lots of different cargo (kayaks, bikes, skiis, etc), the Yakima system is a better option.

kerrton

Offline

288 posts

Lethbridge AB
2-4-2008

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (philipa_240sx)


Thanks Phil, good points.

I mounted the rack on my vehicle last night, and you are right, it does take a bit of extra time and care to mount the feet to the main rails. For me, I will only be using it to carry a roof box (if I ever buy one), and the odd ladder or load of 2x4's. The hardware seems to be heavy duty so I'm confident it won't fail or break - it's all galvanized or otherwise coated steel nuts, bolts and bottom clamp, all of which is covered/hidden by a weather-tight plastic cover....but no doubt the Thule and Yakima products are better quality and easier to use.

The bars are square like the Thule bars, very close in demensions if not identical, but I like them better because they are about a 1/4 of the weight of the Thule. They're light-weight aluminum, and since the overall weight load restrictions for the vehicle is only 100 lbs, you won't be dropping any huge loads on the roof anyway, so I'm sure these bars will be more than sufficient.

If you're going to want to put your rack on and off repeatedly on a regular basis, I probably wouldn't recommend this set up - just pay the extra money and get Thule or Yakima for ease of use. If you're only going to use your rack periodically and you want to save money, than I would recommend this rack, as I'm very happy with it so far.


ahhbeebee

Offline

59 posts

calgary ab
5-14-2008

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (kerrton)


So was that $75 CAD shipped? If you don't mind, please keep posting updates periodically since I'm in the market for a roof top system. I think I've decided the majority of my hauling will be done with a hitch mount system (for bikes and boards), but there certainly will be the occasion for rooftop needs (canoe, and the likes you mention).
kerrton

Offline

288 posts

Lethbridge AB
2-4-2008

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (ahhbeebee)


There is a "make your best offer" button on this item, so I offered $75 bucks American which basically equaled $75 Canadian a few weeks ago. Shipping was $23.00 extra. So the off the shelf Thule package was the cheapest at Canadian Tire for $290. I'm sure the Thule is more durable and definately more user friendly, but the question is how much of a difference is there? I'll be using this rack quite a bit in the next few weeks. so I can let you know how it goes. If money is no object, I would suggest genuine Thule, but I'm looking at another $500 bucks for a roof cargo box so I am happy with the money I saved on the rack, it seems to be really good quality, just takes longer to mount. Email me anytime with more questions...
titefitnmada



Offline

10 posts
2008 Rogue SL AWD
White Marsh MD
5-15-2008

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (kerrton)


This is the same rack I have on my rogue. It can be seen at this post. Thule 695 Xpedition W/ Fairing mounted on Rogue.
(I'm not sure how to make it a link)

http://forums.nicoclub.com/zerothread/354293

philipa_240sx
Moderator



Online

1096 posts
'08 Rogue SL FWD - Iridium Graphite
KW Ont
6-21-2007

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (titefitnmada)


Use the 'insert web link' button on the edit post toolbar. hint: Picture of the earth with a chain link. Then copy and paste the URL:

[url ]http://forums.nicoclub.com/zerothread/354293[/url ]


I've added it to your previous post, click edit to see how it's done.

kerrton

Offline

288 posts

Lethbridge AB
2-4-2008

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (philipa_240sx)


Hey Phil, did you purchase fairing for your Yakima rack? If so, did you notice a really significant difference?

My immitation Thule square bars make this crazy "wooooo" sound when they're without load and I drive over about 90 kph. I'm not sure if the sound will disappear when I add a roof box, and I wonder if the fairing will eliminate the problem? If nothing else, I think the fairing would give the vehicle a unique look and then you could potentially just leave the rack on all the time, rather than just when you need to haul something.

philipa_240sx
Moderator



Online

1096 posts
'08 Rogue SL FWD - Iridium Graphite
KW Ont
6-21-2007

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (kerrton)


No, I never purchased the fairing so I cannot comment on how effective it is.
RiverRogue

Offline

25 posts
2008 Nissan Rogue
Sterling VA
5-1-2008

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (philipa_240sx)


Quote, originally posted by philipa_240sx »
No, I never purchased the fairing so I cannot comment on how effective it is.

The fairing has worked on other cars of mine, but haven't tried it on the Rogue yet.

The Yakima crossbars whistle when the car goes over 45mph. With 2 yaks on it the whistle turns into a mild roar.

I plan on buying a fairing and seeing if it quits the ride

ctof

Offline

2 posts

Livonia MI
11-1-2008

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (RiverRogue)


I saw this thread, and I just got a Rogue with the factory roof rack. I just got some Rocky Mounts brand bike racks to mount onto the factory load bars, but I was wondering if anyone made an aftermarket fairing that would work with the factory bars. I have a Thule rack on my other car, which is an Altima, but the fairing on that will not mount onto the Rogue factory bars.

Please let me know if you know of any fairing that will work or any mod to get another brand fairing to work. I chose to go with the factory bars and mount the rack to that for simplicity.

THX!

ctof

Offline

2 posts

Livonia MI
11-1-2008

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (ctof)


Well, here it is! I did run into a few issues though. Here is what the car looks like with the Rocky Mounts "Noose".

Here is the 3/4 view:

I ran into 2 issues:
#1-The factory crossbars are NOT flat. They have a slight curvature to them, so when you have bikes on them, they are angled out.
#2-The spoiler hits the tray when the tailgate is up.

#3-Because of the bolts in the crossbars, the trays can only be so far apart, and it is a *little* close for 2 bikes. 2 road bikes would be fine, but 2 mountain bikes, the handlebars overlap.

Ah well. I am thinking of cutting a raquet ball in half and capping the ends of the trays. All in all, for simplicity, I would recommend the Rocky Mounts Noose if you are only carrying 1 bike, and don't have the factory spoiler option. For $75 you can't beat it. If you want to carry 2 bikes, I would probably recommend splurging for the Thule set up that other people are showing in this thread.

As far as the fairing that I was wondering about, I tried fitting a Thule fairing in the rack, and didn't fit well. I guess I am going to not get the fairing. If you get the Thule set up, the fairing looks totally smooth. When it attaches to the straight bar, and fits snugly in between the side rails, I dig it.

Schmitty

Offline

6 posts
Rogue
Colorado Springs CO
10-28-2008

 « Re: Rogue Roof Rack Options (ctof)


So last weekend I got a chance to try out my thule crossroad 450 with ski carrier setup. While you can't beat the convenience of being able to toss the skis on the roof instead of having to pull down a seat, my big complaint was wind noise. It was a really nice day so I had the moonroof open.
I got aprox 25mpg from this trip which I think is pretty good considering the rack, skis, mountain driving and my leadfoot.
Unfortunately for me there's no fairing option that I can use thanks to that moonroof, but since I can't hear the rack with it closed it's not a huge issue, as days like sunday will be rare for this ski season.
 

» Return to Rogue Forum
Forum Jump
Quick Reply

Powered by ZeroForum 2.4.0. ©2008 RelyNet, Inc.



< Contact Us - NICO >

Copyright © 2000-2008 by NICO


Google
Web NICOclub.com