Nissan Forums | Infiniti Forums NICOclub staff, History and Advertising eMail NICOclub Webmaster Advertising on NICOclub Nissan forums
 
          

Active Topics

Quick Reply  Print  Email  Subscribe RSS  Help
 For the "What Coilover should i get" type threadsFirst  1 2 >  Last
Author Post
yokota180sx
"Fun Sponge"

Offline

2982 posts
1996 Y33 cedric/1997 Stagea
Akiruno shi tokyo
11-19-2006

  For the "What Coilover should i get" type threads


Ok guys, i know everyone views me as a dick or whatnot but just give me a few moments of your time


Why do you want the coilover?
Don't say DD
If you want it to drive around everyday, its because you want to be slammed
If not, then don't buy coilovers for DD
They are rough and harsh 80% of the time
If you want to fix the harshness, find a company called Sprint Springs (or others)and order yourself or 6/5 or lower springs
The coilovers will still function as well as they did before
After all, it would be for DD right?


You Track guys
Ok, understand, it doesn't matter if your going to do grip or drift
All these coilovers will do the same thing
Its all in how you ADJUST THEM
varying dampening and spring rates

So really, it all matters in the brand and setup you choose in how you want it to handle in whatever aspect it should

Getting opinions?
Before you hover your little 14 year old finger over the New Thread button, read this

95% of people that comment on coilovers, have only owned one set, or have ridden in a car with them

once you understand that, and get past it, you will be fine

the people you need to listen to are the few of us that have had 4 or 5+ coilover sets
Every coilover (well not so much these days) are distinct. Anyone that has ridden in a car with Cusco and one with JIC can tell you they handle with varying degrees of difference.
all the Megan/kts/lower stance/etc etc all will handle the same, so it doesn't matter
The thing however with the generic 1200< coilovers is the dampening
K sport for a fact has an over dampened rear which makes it unpredictable
i don't recommend them at all, and i own a set. I barely drive my Stagea because of them
id rather have blown JICs than have them

Regardless, please don't make a Which Coilover thread

Unless your going to make a specific thread on a specific topic, there is no need.

No one will be able to tell you what you need, only finding a car with the coilovers you want to, and either riding in or driving will allow you to make an informed decision (except for rare cases of people that know what they are talking about for that particular brand(s))

anyways, thats my 2 cents
and to make it a yokota post

**** off




Need Wheels, or JDM parts?
Call me 8435646003, please take into account time change differences.

slik_s13

Offline

378 posts
1990 nissan 240sx hatch back
espanola new mexico
3-23-2006

 « Re: For the "What Coilover should i get" type threads (yokota180sx)


haha nice thread!



FS: electric sun roof for s13 coupe
sr20det a/c compressor

AZhitman
CEO



Offline

44271 posts
03 G35C s/c, 93 S13 Vert KA-T, 72 240Z, 63 NL320, 67.5 SPL311, 69 and 70 SPL311s, '69 510
Phx, AZ
4-29-2002

 « 


Man, if Grant could spell, he'd be amazing.

Good stuff.



TEAM NICO: 110,000 Nissan enthusiasts strong.

Add a link to NICOclub to your site!

...even the HITMAN is on MySpace

Stacey Lynn Childs 1970-2007... Love of my life, my best friend, Heaven's prettiest angel. I miss you so much.

E7-S14



Offline

3770 posts
ess 14 foo!
that dark ally
6-25-2006

 « Re: (AZhitman)



Sticky?
the majority of people seeking suspension advice don't go to the suspension forum.. so only a majority of people are not going to see this whish is the suckors

but yeah..+1.29938 for good (not ball crushing) thread/advice...




Top Dead Center "Power Through Precision"


-Black 95 S14_N/A S14 SR
sip

Offline

966 posts
1989 Nissan 180SX
Halifax Nova Scotia
8-24-2006

 « Re: YOKOTA


I like the "new" Yokota, he's much more tactful than the 'old' Yokota.
Keep it up Grant!

PS. I used your tire stretch thread to explain it to people on Jbody.org. +1



Quote, originally posted by My Wife »
What did you do to the car

Quote, originally posted by Me »
Put the coilovers on

Quote, originally posted by My Wife »
It hurts my boobs

Quote, originally posted by Me »
I'll get you a SPORTS BRA!

Beancooker
Administrator



Offline

7581 posts
'04 Infiniti G35
Lacey Wa
6-26-2006

 « Re: YOKOTA (sip)


Nice. Good article yoko...

Sip, I love your sig.




Quote, originally posted by numbnuts240 »
or pink eye, in which case you should really make sure whatever girl you are eating out washes her *** before the 69 begins.



sip

Offline

966 posts
1989 Nissan 180SX
Halifax Nova Scotia
8-24-2006

 « Re: YOKOTA (beancooker)


Quote, originally posted by beancooker »

Sip, I love your sig.

I showed the wife, she schoffed.
I'm thinking of making a 'flash' version

BOOMSHAKALAKA

Offline

5608 posts

Hell
6-23-2006

 « Re: For the "What Coilover should i get" type threads (yokota180sx)


Quote, originally posted by yokota180sx »
and to make it a yokota post

**** off

Hahahaaaaaa it's about time you made this thread!



1996 Jeep Grand Cherokee Limited-Daily driver
1994 Nissan 240SX SE convertible-Stock and slow
Scuffed_ChukiCoupe



Offline

1965 posts
no more 91 coupe, or zenki
Westchester PA
7-9-2007

 « Re: For the "What Coilover should i get" type threads (BOOMSHAKALAKA)


Ok i dunno if this belongs here but w.e someone will answer me. I really really really want coilovers. I can deal wit the road harshness its nothing to me, i ride around with no radio and ac. BUT im poor and i really need my car to be dropped right now. Ill be making a trip to orlando driving in about 6 months and my mom and bro are coming with me so i dont really want to get coilovers for the road may be harsh 4 them. Being said though i really want coilovers i cant wait to save so long other parts of my car need attention. What is the best strut spring combo thats going to give me the lowest drop. Any other advice u can offer for me while shopping for suspension would be great. Dont worry yokota ill stay away from k-sport.



A new coupe this summer!

yokota180sx
"Fun Sponge"

Offline

2982 posts
1996 Y33 cedric/1997 Stagea
Akiruno shi tokyo
11-19-2006

 « 


if you can deal with it Powereed by max
Eikon
Super Moderator



Offline

6895 posts
'92 240sx 'vert with RB20
hidden
4-24-2004

 « Re: (yokota180sx)


Great thread dude!!



http://www.240sxconvertible.com - The internet's only 240sx 'vert site!

Joshua 1:9 "Have I not commanded you? Be strong and courageous. Do not be terrified; do not be discouraged, for the LORD your God will be with you wherever you go."

Scuffed_ChukiCoupe



Offline

1965 posts
no more 91 coupe, or zenki
Westchester PA
7-9-2007

 « Re: (yokota180sx)


Quote, originally posted by yokota180sx »
if you can deal with it Powereed by max

But those are in the coilover price range, right?

Scuffed_ChukiCoupe



Offline

1965 posts
no more 91 coupe, or zenki
Westchester PA
7-9-2007

 « Re: (Scuffed_ChukiCoupe)


For some reason i was under the impression that strut a spring combo was like under 500 bucks but i see that its not. So might as well save for the megan tracks i want.
redtop91
Meat Gazer



Offline

16166 posts
↑ ↑ ↓ ↓ ← → ← → B A Start
Broken Arrow OK
9-7-2006

 « Re: (Scuffed_ChukiCoupe)


If you want camber plates and crap a strut/spring setup is going to cost as much as an entry coilover like Megan. Anyways the "new" yokota is much better than the old. Still a douchebag but at least semi-helpful. And good for a laugh/ban.




Feint of Heart
Crystal Baller



Offline

1063 posts
1990 240sx Fastback
PA
1-11-2006

 « Re: (Scuffed_ChukiCoupe)


Quote, originally posted by Scuffed_ChukiCoupe »

But those are in the coilover price range, right?

They're $1050 shipped anywhere in the US.

http://www.poweredbymax.net



-Adam
Pignose Squad #83 Stock '90 FB/KA24DE/S15 Spec R Seats
|PA Drifting
|

Scuffed_ChukiCoupe



Offline

1965 posts
no more 91 coupe, or zenki
Westchester PA
7-9-2007

 « Re: (Feint of Heart)


yea for that price i can get megan tracks and some good quality sway bars. For now ill stick to megan springs with my minimum wage paychecks.
nieko



Offline

550 posts
1989 Nissan 240sx
Westminster CA
12-4-2006

 « Re: (Scuffed_ChukiCoupe)


yakota have you ever used stance pros? a lot of ppl on here will recomend them and i was kinda leaning towards them. they sound like they deliver. but in ur first post u said stance and megan and k sport are all the same?



FS: Hatch Part out

FS: Paintball stuff

FS: Hatcback 1/4 Window

FS: Memphis audio 6.5

yokota180sx
"Fun Sponge"

Offline

2982 posts
1996 Y33 cedric/1997 Stagea
Akiruno shi tokyo
11-19-2006

 « 


lower stances basics are


nieko



Offline

550 posts
1989 Nissan 240sx
Westminster CA
12-4-2006

 « Re: (yokota180sx)


ya thats what i heard, thats why im staying away from the basics. it seems like all the basics of like every brand are pretty much the same.
pat93

Offline

144 posts

san jose ca
2-8-2007

 « Re: For the "What Coilover should i get" type threads (yokota180sx)


how is greddy type -s ?
Just wonder, numbers of brands are repeatedly mentioned in here except
greddy. how is it?
yokota180sx
"Fun Sponge"

Offline

2982 posts
1996 Y33 cedric/1997 Stagea
Akiruno shi tokyo
11-19-2006

 « 


cant mention it if ive never used it

i cant tell you

SERUM



Offline

90 posts

NashVegas
8-19-2007

 « Re: (yokota180sx)


Quote, originally posted by yokota180sx »
if you can deal with it Powereed by max

Are they that bad? I bring my son everywhere with me (he's 2), so can I get the sprint's and put on them when the funds recoup?



Quote, originally posted by Dr.Fate »
Sorry I had to vent, for people that steal cars, just know that when you die I hope you get ear,mouth and analy raped by a bear in hell.

"You come at me you better know, I move quick... and when I do, I slice...like a goddamn hammer."
yokota180sx
"Fun Sponge"

Offline

2982 posts
1996 Y33 cedric/1997 Stagea
Akiruno shi tokyo
11-19-2006

 « 


to me
no its not bad
to others, its harsh

its all relative, but i have 18k/16k springs in my stagea, so i like a rather firm ride
its not tat bad

phanatikz32
la última nuez de suspensión



Offline

870 posts
1991 NA z32
San Bernardino CA
11-5-2006

 « Re: (yokota180sx)


so brand is irrelevant? megan coilovers will do just as good as TEIN or JIC?

Modified by phanatikz32 at 12:39 PM 12/26/2007



=
Quote, originally posted by phanatikz32 »
chicks love z32's

S14-KOUKI-MONSTER



Offline

296 posts
'97.5 Kouki s14 le w/Kouki s14 sr & '03 Xterra w/6" lift on 33s
Vancouver Island B.C.
4-17-2006

 « Re: (redtop91)


Quote, originally posted by redtop91 »
Anyways the "new" yokota is much better than the old. Still a douchebag but at least semi-helpful. And good for a laugh/ban.

I'm buying new suspension soon and was going to start a poll, but like you said the feedback will be uninformed. The s14 is my daily driver from april-oct/nov. and then I take it off the road for the winter. However I will be auto-crossing it next spring/summer, so I want some good coilovers.

I've decide that I want to have pillowball mounts, and an electronic dampening force controller, so the way I see it, I have three choices.
Tanabe sustec pro7
Cusco zero-2e
Tein super drift

I was leaning towards cusco, but they only have 5 way dampening adjustability, so now I'm leaning towards tanabe. I've heard that tein is over-rated from people that have owned/still own them.

So in your opinions, what would be the best bet?



Death Before Dishonor.

yokota180sx
"Fun Sponge"

Offline

2982 posts
1996 Y33 cedric/1997 Stagea
Akiruno shi tokyo
11-19-2006

 « 


cuscoi realllly like cusco
tein is too soft

andn tanabae....well they are in the middle of everyone to me. They arent bad, but they dont stand out

i reallllly liked my cuscos on my FD3S

simmode1



Offline

1453 posts
1993 chuki & 1996 zenki
Euless TX
8-17-2007

 « Re: For the "What Coilover should i get" type threads (yokota180sx)


Wow. I really wish I knew this thread was here b4 I posted my "Which coilovers' thread a few days ago! lol!

But I do still need help! Currently, I have KYB adjustable AGX struts/shocks with Tein S-Tech springs. But my s13 feels far crappier than I would have expected.

Anybody around the DFW area wanna drive my car and help me troubleshoot?



Quote, originally posted by tonynalli »
^^^this man speakith the truth.

Quote, originally posted by Rod_Chong »
But seeing this damage caused me pain.... I suppose, if you drift a car then you need to expect to crash it. Probably one reason I have no inclination to drift...

S13 Project Cloud current status: KYB AGX shocks/struts, Tein S-Tech springs, Suspension Techniques front/rear sway bars, Ebay front/rear strut bars, Hawk HPS brake pads, Powerslot Slotted Rotors, Agency Power braided brake lines w/Motul fluid, Exedy Stage 1 Racing Clutch, Fidanza Aluminum Flywheel, AEM short ram, Custom 2.5 exhaust. Wheels: 17x7.5 w/30mm rear spacer(Super Fail ).

S14 Project Red XIV current status: Tokico Blue shocks/struts, Eibach Pro springs, 18x8.5+33 Z33 Anniversary wheels all around

Camry



Offline

676 posts
96' Camry. 92' 240sx. 03' Evo
Philadelphia Pa
10-7-2006

 « Re: For the "What Coilover should i get" type threads (simmode1)


Thanks for the inputs Yokota. I was really leaning towards Stance GR+ for a couple months but since you mentioned Powered By Max in a couple of threads, I started doing some research and I'm leaning towards them now.



"I can remember every gear shift and every braking distance for the 187 corners of the Nurburgring, but I can't even read or remember the National Anthem or the Lord's Prayers"
-Sir 'Jackie' Stewart
seejaytoo



Offline

214 posts
1993 240sx Hatch
Ames IA
10-16-2006

 « Re: For the "What Coilover should i get" type threads (Camry)


ive got a question for the wheel/tire/suspension guru (yoko) , so i have 12/10 megan tracks. i love um, tho i have nothing to compare to. I do get bounced quite a bit on bumpy roads, its nothing i cant deal with, but say like some cuscos with the same spring rate. Will those be more stable, is that the difference between lower and higher quality, or am i set up wrong, or is that just effed up arkansas roads and its no big deal. dont get me wrong, im not complaining, id take my megans over stock anyday, but at some point id like to move up (when i get more cash) Basically, what will i see/feel different between my megans and say cusco, zeal, HKS ... top brands
dunno if i make sense but thanks anyway




By seejaytoo
yokota180sx
"Fun Sponge"

Offline

2982 posts
1996 Y33 cedric/1997 Stagea
Akiruno shi tokyo
11-19-2006

 « Re: For the "What Coilover should i get" type threads (seejaytoo)


i mean, 10/8 + on an s chassis isnt going ot be remotely comfortable to 90% of the nissan drivers

with that said, its all in HOW you feel the bumps
do they make the car hop, do they just make it bounce after the bump, or does it absorb it, and just keep going

its all in HOW you feel the bumps. IMO a good coilover will absorb the bump(at 12/10s however, youll still get josled) and level out after that bump. It shouldnt take 2 or 3 strokes to get it to stop bouncing


Quote, originally posted by seejaytoo »
ive got a question for the wheel/tire/suspension guru (yoko) , so i have 12/10 megan tracks. i love um, tho i have nothing to compare to. I do get bounced quite a bit on bumpy roads, its nothing i cant deal with, but say like some cuscos with the same spring rate. Will those be more stable, is that the difference between lower and higher quality, or am i set up wrong, or is that just effed up arkansas roads and its no big deal. dont get me wrong, im not complaining, id take my megans over stock anyday, but at some point id like to move up (when i get more cash) Basically, what will i see/feel different between my megans and say cusco, zeal, HKS ... top brands
dunno if i make sense but thanks anyway

seejaytoo



Offline

214 posts
1993 240sx Hatch
Ames IA
10-16-2006

 « Re: For the "What Coilover should i get" type threads (yokota180sx)


oh ok i get it, your stagea is heavier im sure, thats why you can run the 18/16, right?
yeah it just a little hop. It jarrs you a little doesnt really bounce that much, it levels out pretty quickly.
so with a 12/10 on an s chassis its gonna be bumpy, but a good coilover with dampen better... less bounce. am i on the right track? but say a 10/8 will pick up the bumps better? Again, am i remotely close?
RBbugBITme

Offline

72 posts
92 hatchback
Philadelphia/Yardley PA
3-9-2006

 « 


I don't even know where to start and I don't want to get to in depth with this but most of whats been said is fairly useless.

The best piece of advice I can give to anyone looking to buy springs/shocks, just go to meets and ask to get a ride in other peoples cars. Everything from shock absorber piston design (who has actually seen one?), owner knowledge, ride height, alignment specs, tire spring rate (thats never talked about), linear/nonlinear (usually very non-linear) rebound/dampening adjustment knobs, etc. etc. etc. make any opinion about any coilover or shock/spring combo totally useless. Ask yourself when was the last back to back skidpad/slalom/track time comparison you saw between different setups let alone different adjustment settings on the same set up. Who here has seen let alone understood a shock dyno graph?

After I graduate I'll have the time to redesign the entire suspension for lowered 240's but I know enough that if I enjoy the ride of a cheap spring and shock combo vs. a 32 way (total BS) $1700 coilover, I'm saving my money for now.

Something I've noticed and thought was pretty interesting is that most people try to emulate almost every aspect of successful race cars except the suspension. 20+ way adjustable coilovers just aren't seen on real race cars, its a gimmick and from everything I've read (because I don't have the money to conduct days of shock dyno comparisons) every company listed in this thread are great on marketing, bad on engineering.

The responses to this should be interesting... Again newbs, just go ask to get a ride at local meets and feel for yourself if you like it and ask what he's got. We usually don't say no.



-Ryan
http://www.PdV-Motorsports.com
'08 Drexel Formula SAE Team Captain
yokota180sx
"Fun Sponge"

Offline

2982 posts
1996 Y33 cedric/1997 Stagea
Akiruno shi tokyo
11-19-2006

 « Re: (RBbugBITme)


wow
so you completely restated my first post..

good job

BUT
this thread isnt for people that care abou good **** liek the few of us that do.
Its for people that want a budget coilover to be low and stiff, but still handle decently
so yeah.

RBbugBITme

Offline

72 posts
92 hatchback
Philadelphia/Yardley PA
3-9-2006

 « Re: (yokota180sx)


Actually I did not. You gave a number of opinions on a number of different coilovers.

I'm saying, you're opinion means nothing to anyone but you when everyone reading it will have different ride heights, tires, ARB's, total weight and distribution, brakes, typical area road conditions (holed up city streets or not) and feeling for what is too stiff/soft, etc.
I'm saying, the best way to decide on what set up to get is to go to a local meet or autox and ask for rides so you can feel it yourself.

Modified by RBbugBITme at 10:13 AM 11/27/2007

yokota180sx
"Fun Sponge"

Offline

2982 posts
1996 Y33 cedric/1997 Stagea
Akiruno shi tokyo
11-19-2006

 « Re: For the "What Coilover should i get" type threads (yokota180sx)


Quote, originally posted by yokota180sx »
\

No one will be able to tell you what you need, only finding a car with the coilovers you want to, and either riding in or driving will allow you to make an informed decision

anyways, thats my 2 cents
and to make it a yokota post

**** off


from first post
RBbugBITme

Offline

72 posts
92 hatchback
Philadelphia/Yardley PA
3-9-2006

 « Re: For the "What Coilover should i get" type threads (yokota180sx)


Also from the first post,

"Cusco and one with JIC can tell you they handle with varying degrees of difference.
all the Megan/kts/lower stance/etc etc all will handle the same, so it doesn't matter
The thing however with the generic 1200< coilovers is the dampening
K sport for a fact has an over dampened rear which makes it unpredictable
i don't recommend them at all, and i own a set. I barely drive my Stagea because of them
id rather have blown JICs than have them"

End of discussion.

MrPresidentQ45



Offline

55 posts
1999 Q45 1999 G20 1978 KZ1000 LTD
Citrus Heights California
11-21-2007

 « Re: For the "What Coilover should i get" type threads (RBbugBITme)


I'm trying to sort out a suspension setup for my 240, and from every thread I've looked in so far (here and on other forums) it seems to be that:
1. If you spend less than $1,000 on a coilover setup (K-sport, etc.) , you might as well have taken your money, thrown it on the ground and lit it on fire. And then P***** on it.
2. If you want to build any sort of track car (weekend), either man up and spend at least $1,500 or more on a high-line model set-up from a known brand (Tein, Cusco, etc.), or run some sort of shock/sleve top mount combo that costs as much or more.
3. (and this is me) While personal preference with regards to ride quality is a given, there doesn't seem to be an answer to the basic everyman question, which (reading between the lines and bad english) seems to be "I want my car to sit lower and handle better than stock. Will coilovers (by brand, or in general) accomplish this, or is there a better suggestion (upgrade struts and springs)?"

I'm not talking about shock dyno testing (saw that on zylvia) or even "what does the seat of YOUR pants say?" but has anyone run a track car in a controlled environment (say, a road course) and then improved the suspension, resulting in a reduction in lap time or some other measureable event?

From personal experience on other vehicles basic things like bigger swaybars, stiffer springs and "performance" shocks (anything other than stock is performance when you're dealing with 60's suspension) reduce body roll (and increase ride harshness) and generally allow the vehicle to handle better up to the limits of the tires. I would imagine the same applies here. What results have others had and with what setups? Sorry about the run-on Kerouac sentences, I'd just like to avoid wasting my cash on a setup that does nothing.

yokota180sx
"Fun Sponge"

Offline

2982 posts
1996 Y33 cedric/1997 Stagea
Akiruno shi tokyo
11-19-2006

 « Re: For the "What Coilover should i get" type threads (RBbugBITme)


Quote, originally posted by RBbugBITme »
Also from the first post,

"Cusco and one with JIC can tell you they handle with varying degrees of difference.
all the Megan/kts/lower stance/etc etc all will handle the same, so it doesn't matter
The thing however with the generic 1200< coilovers is the dampening
K sport for a fact has an over dampened rear which makes it unpredictable
i don't recommend them at all, and i own a set. I barely drive my Stagea because of them
id rather have blown JICs than have them"

End of discussion.

notice, you quoted the beginning of my post

not the end...
quit being a smartass and stfu

RBbugBITme

Offline

72 posts
92 hatchback
Philadelphia/Yardley PA
3-9-2006

 « 


MrPresident, typically anyone that has done any type of back to back analysis, especially on a road course, is doing it for serious competition purposes and wouldn't share their results.
4bangers

Offline

67 posts
91 240SX
bellevue wa
10-4-2007

 « Re: (RBbugBITme)


so I got cusco zero-2r coilover and the spring is only 7/5. So if I want to drift, do I have to increase the dampening to make it stiffer? can I drift with 7/5 spring or do I have to get higher spring rate?
 First  1 2 >  Last

» Return to Tires, Wheels, Brakes and Suspension
Forum Jump