My vote toofloat_6969 wrote:My vote will always be for standalone.
He may not be doing the tuning himself. If that is the case, ask the tuner what system he like for your car, and get it. If he/she says SAFC, find a new tuner.Not_a_sr wrote:put on the wideband, then up the boost if your AFRS need adjusting then go with a SAFC,Rom tune, or standalone.
hes probably setup for 450s or 550s on that ecu. i would get a wideband next to know what your AFR's are actually at. with out it you wont be doing any good wuth a SAFC youll be "tuning" in the dark,and that is probably more dangerous then throwing on a wideband and upping the boost on the current ECU.
my purchases would be wideband,cheap o boost controller,and some sort of way to alter your fueling.
Worst advice ever. The tuner has to look at it as a cost/benefit analysis for the cutomer. Let's say hell freezes over and I take my car into a shop to have it "tuned". The team asks me what my goals are, and I tell them the truth: 250rwhp, no more than $2k more from where I am now. That is the max that I honestly want, so a ROM tune and a SAFC to clean up the map with proper accessories (Z32 AFM, T28, 460ccs, etc). That is solid advice, as a stand alone is ~$1000, with that much again in tuning from the shop. So, what I could do in ROM and AFC for $800-$1000 TUNED, might just be a better value for ME. Now, what his goals and needs are, I do not know. But I am saying that just because a shop is honest and dosen't charge you out the a$$ unnecessiarly is a GOOD thing!Coldspawn wrote:He may not be doing the tuning himself. If that is the case, ask the tuner what system he like for your car, and get it. If he/she says SAFC, find a new tuner.
Yes, they should. They should also know how and why a product is better then another. SAFC is garage. No good tuner in their right mind will tune it with a FI or NA. Read what I posted in "Ecu tuning question?" thread about it.rico05 wrote: The tuner has to look at it as a cost/benefit analysis for the cutomer.
Well, that is not solid advice because there is a few great stand-alones out there for less then $1000.rico05 wrote: That is solid advice, as a stand alone is ~$1000,
Better value? I think a $200-400 more for a tune on a better EMS is cheaper then a new motor. Not to mention less time too.rico05 wrote:So, what I could do in ROM and AFC for $800-$1000 TUNED, might just be a better value for ME.
Well, you can look short term or long time. I think SAFC is a short-term fix. I never tune with "short term" in mind, sorry.rico05 wrote: Now, what his goals and needs are, I do not know. But I am saying that just because a shop is honest and dosen't charge you out the a$$ unnecessiarly is a GOOD thing!
Explain to me why it is bad advice. Not every tuner knows/likes every software/stand-alone out there. Like I said, talk to your tuner what you think is good for your set-up. Then do research on what he says. If he likes SAFC, he is either: Bad tuner or does not kind about your car.rico05 wrote:Worst advice ever.
I am sorry that you are closed minded. You drop names like I give a damn. I am sorry you think this way. I think it is sad that people are like you. You do not like me because of what I posted on the internet, get a life.rico05 wrote:INo, I will not go read your thread, no matter what you may have said. I do not trust you know what you are talking about, I am sorry.
rico05 wrote:And for folks that want some better info than Mr. Spawn has to offer, here is a good place to start:http://store.yahoo.com/sgpraci....html
Hehe, personal attacks, I love it. You know what cars I have work on or my racing history? Nope. You got mad on the internet because of what I said. That is sad and funny at the same time.rico05 wrote:Also, you can try asking the user "mikehutch711", as he has a VERY nicely tuned CA (GT28, etc) with a SAFC and JWT ECU. He is someone that has more experience than Mr. Spawn with a SAFC on a CA18DET.