Throckmorton wrote:
I am of the opinion that you will never 'feel' the difference that this pulley will make. I think all you are doing is slowing down your A/C compressor, your power steering pump, and your alternator by 20%.
The Altima 3.5 is rated by the factory as having 270 HP @ 6000 rpm. Will the addition of the new pulley allow you to rev your motor to even higher rpm's?
I realize that the A/C, P/S and alternator are parasites, and drain HP from the motor. It does take horsepower to spin them. How much HP and at what rpm is the question.
I am in no way bashing Stillen, as I know they are a first class organization. I know they make quality products, and have a very good reputation.
Stillen's comment on their website that " we’ve seen power gains of up to 10+ HP at the wheels." to me is meaningless taken at face value.
Questions that need to be asked of Stillen are:
What vehicle got 10 more HP? What size engine got 10 more HP? What belt driven accessories did the engine that 'gained up to 10+ HP "have? A/C, P/S, or did it only have an alternator?What other modifications did this engine have?Was the engine factory stock?
Where are the dynamometer test results that prove the claimed horsepower gain?
Specifically, what HP gain was observed in a L-32 Nissan Altima 3.5 V-6?
Notice that Stillen does not claim a specific HP gain, only a general statement.
Here are some questions that you should be asking yourself about this pulley change:
Did Nissan put a 4.32 lb pulley on the end of the crankshaft, instead of a lighter 1.00 lb. pulley, because it acts as some type of harmonic balancer?
Will this pulley change void my warranty?
Will this pulley subject my engine to undo stress?
Good luck, and I hope this works out for you.
You're posting in multiple threads, I'll try to keep up.. and answer the questions as you've presented them.
If you have the chance to drive a car with the pulley installed, you will feel the difference, as many people have. It's reducing the rotating mass on the crank pulley, most people describe the sensation as it "revs faster".
The factory rating of 270hp @ 6000 rpm is describing the RPM at the peak of it's horsepower performance. The rev limiter is controlled by the ECU, and is unaffected by the installation of a pulley.
Anything that is connected to the motor and needs power to turn is going to rob the driveline of horsepower. The pulleys free this up in the exact relation to the power needed from the accessories (in the underdrive configuration).
Thank you for the kind words regarding STILLEN.
Lightweight and underdrive pulleys have been used for years for countless vehicles, and are regarded as a nice upgrade in line with the typical bolt-ons. We did not dyno the 3.5L Altima, the vehicles we've done development on have been CVTs, which will not provide a consistent dyno run.
Most do not pay the expense to specifically have the pulleys dyno'd.. more likely to do a combination of parts, exhaust, intakes, headers etc, which explains the lack of specific dynos on each vehicle.
The 3.5L engine in the Altima is internally balanced, and does not require a harmonic balancer. If you look at the OEM crank pulley, you will see that the steel pulley does contain a rubber ring separating the outside area from the inside, which actually provides some NVH (noise, vibration, harshness) from actually heading back into the engine, due to the cast design. With a perfectly balanced aftermarket pulley, this isn't a concern.
Regarding your warranty.. this is similar to typical bolt-on accessories offered from the aftermarket. It's been discussed a 1,000 times over, I won't rehash it, except to say there are laws in place to help unfamiliar dealerships from voiding warranties regarding non-OEM parts. We have a tremendous relationship with Nissan, and all of our parts are available and installed at hundreds of dealerships across the country, and these pulleys are no different.
This pulley will not add stress to your engine, it is in fact increasing the efficiency by removing rotational mass from the driveline, hence the performance increases. The pulley is CAD machined from a solid block of aluminum, and is perfectly balanced.
That was a lot of typing.. I appreciate your questions, and hope I was able to shed some light on this for you.