Tr0uble wrote:
Even if the stock housing was intended for HID?Both housings for S15 Headlights are identical ignoring the fact of one has HIDs and other doesn't. One is $2,200 and the other is $650.
The problem is that the stock housing is not intended for HID in the fog light portion. A brief explanation for this is that a filament has a very definitive light shape with sharp cutoffs around the cylinder of the filament and fading ends. An arc capsule produces a filament-like shape, but does not have a sharp cutoff, and is actually more of an arc in overall shape as opposed to a filiament's straght shape. When you consider that the light source is the size of a 1/4" long pencil lead, you can only imagine how seeming small differences in the light source shape and intensity throughout can really affect the beam pattern when it is projected across a reflector and/or a lens. As a result, the lens and reflector system is different so that the light is projected onto the road correctly. Light distribution is very important for maximizing visibility where it is most needed and in ordernot to blind others on the road.
Headlights are not floodlights where you just need to saturate the road with as much light as possible. While that might be ideal for visibility, it would completely blind others on the road. The human eye responds differently in dark conditions than it does during the day. Add too much light in the foreground (the area directly in front of the car) and you're distance vision will suffer. Same is true anywhere else within your view. There has to be a certain amount of light balance to achieve good visibilty. and all this must be done so that the beam pattern and intensity will not reduce vision for other drivers. As simple as lighting would seem to be, it's not. For visibility, particularly for distance vision, turning on the fog lights under normal circumstances would actually hurt distance visibility as it provides a lot of foreground light.
Here's a much more detailed article about HID retrofitting. Poke around the tech articles on the site as well. You'll find a lot of useful lighting info in a lot more detail than you will probably need:
http://www.danielsternlighting....html