colonelcasey wrote:I think I might have some 2000 grit sand paper lying around. Should I use this or something more coarse to get out the jaggies?
This come down to time/effort versus value. I am sure you will still get what you are looking for if you use the 2000 grit to remove the edges, perhaps even rough up a little bit of the surrounding area (so that it bonds to it).
That said, I would feel guilty if I didn't mention other ways to do it. A trip to your autobody supply store would probably yield some great results if you can talk to the counter staff. A more advanced way to do it would be to smooth out the scratch with some wetsanding, wetsand a little bit of the surrounding area (so that it can adhere), use some sort of filler that is made for plastic parts that flex (ideally you would use some sort of adhesion promoter too, but that might add a bit to the cost for such a small scratch), get the area perfectly clean (tack cloth if need be), apply thin layers of paint, then apply clear coat. Wet sand any high spots.
As you can see, this would take a lot of time and possibly cost a lot of money because of the variety of materials. It may also be challenging it such a small area.
What I like is that the first method is relatively inexpensive to try. And let's face it, you can use the pen to fill in all your other rock chips so it's not a huge waste. If you do not like how it looks, you can always go with method #2 (or whatever you research/want to do). I just don't want you to walk away thinking to touchup pen is the only solution if you do not like how it looks.
The Nissan dealer will sell touch-up pens that match the paint of your vehicle. They come with 2 ends - one paint, one clear coat. I have not looked for any aftermarket alternatives myself so I cannot comment on a place that has them both. If you cannot find a 2-in-1 pen, you can always buy a clear coat pen by itself:
https://www.turtlewax.com/shop/products ... -30-fl-oz-