theboz wrote:Planning on doing a swap into my S13. Don't know if I want to go CA, SR, or RB. I am in the military and have a wife and kids so I will DEFINITELY be on a tight budget. How hard would it be to get about 275 to 300whp of of a CA18? Any help would be appreciated. Thanks.
OK... I actually came to look in the CA forum for some random stuff... but saw this and thought I'd put my 2 cents in...
Someone said something about making power easier with a RB or SR... well the only adv of either is displacement (considering the cost effective RB20 for the RB alternative)... and they have the same displacement... so... the SR has the adv on weight right there... this is coming from someone with an RB20 by the way.
One thing to consider is power band... not just power... if you want your power down low... search for anything greater than 2.0L. Not to say you can't have torque down low with a 2.0... but you'll always have more with a comparable flowing motor (head, CR, and manifolds) with more displacement... ie an RB25+
Since you are on a tight budget you will probably be only doing bolt-ons outside the motor... maybe cams... correct?
I would eliminate the RB20 from your list... I did this motor because I found it interesting... not because it makes more power... 2.0L is 2.0L ok... in 12cyl or 4cyl... you can only pump so much air with a given total displacement. Bore and stroke change... along with some other variables, but total volume is the same. To clear things up though... my RB20 handles very well and is quite balanced... they do not weigh much more than the KA does...
The key to which motor to choose in the CA or SR would deal primarily on intake manifold design... someone has to say, since I don't know, where the peak power is made on the stock CA's manifold and SR's manifold... without forgetting cams... where these two items put max power is going to establish your build up. If the CA makes peak power around 6500... look for around 280bhp by calculation at 1bar of boost. To make this same bhp level with an SR you could make this power by about 5900 with the same boost pressure.
I don't like KA's... so I'm not going to recommend one. Bias... yes... but heavy 2.4L 4cyl truck motors don't do anything for me.
I like CA's and RB's way more than SR's for tech reasons... but I'd recommend a SR for someone on a 300hp goal budget. Since weight does matter in the way power is applied and not in dyno charts... I think an SR with proper intake manifold and exhaust plumbing should yield the best power per dollar. Just throw on a T3/T4, as much as I don't like them (I hear the S15 stock turbo is good for your power levels if you can swing it), boost controller, fuel management, FMIC, pump, fuel regulator, and fuel injectors and call it a day.
I think this will give you the most effective power curve per dollar with a bit if reliablity instead of swinging a slap-together job in there just to say you have 300hp.
Ok... so it turned into a $1.50... but I hope it helps.