I'm comparing the full wheel + tire height.
Check this out:
http://www.1010tires.com/tiresizecalculator.asp
The overall diamater for stock wheel+tire is 664.21 mm
For a 45 profile tire it's 677.67 mm For 35 it's 628.65 mm
Basically your overall wheel diameter is a lot smaller than stock. Might be affecting your speedo.
Those Rotas would fill out the wheel gap nicer with a bigger sidewall too.
I remember you saying that you were upgrading to 19's tho, in which case a 35 profile tire gives roughly stock diameter.