JakemzZ wrote:Mrfeeslaw do you have a pcv delete? If so are you having any problems with your engine bay getting a little dirty from the oil breathers? I need to buy an oil catch can.
I may have to do a write-up on this one... I had a short 30 second answer, but I started doing a little more research and talking with my automotive science instructor, and things got complicated quickly.
The short answer is yes, I am going to be modifying my PCV. Not sure if I will be deleting completely or not. The PCV in normal N/A application will probably be fine to delete. The blow-by in the cylinders can easily be managed by atmospheric pressure. Therefore, you can remove the PCV and just put a tube on it, and it will not lower engine performance. This will also keep oil and crankcase gases from returning to the intake, which will help with a cleaner Air/Fuel mixture, and keep engine turbulence smooth, allowing for better air flow.
The problem with removing the PCV comes when you start talking about boost, and high compression. Both of these factors create higher cylinder pressures and cause more blow-by into the crankcase. The problem with this, is that the atmospheric pressure may not be a low enough pressure to pull all of the gases out of the crankcase fast enough, and you may end up building pressure in your crankcase, which can damage seals, cause oil leaks, and in extreme cases can even blow off the valve covers and damage internals.
This means, that on a boosted engine, it would actually be better to leave the PCV on the vehicle, and install a quality catch can between the PCV and the intake. The reason you want to leave the PCV system attached to the intake is to get the vacuum pressure of the intake to pull the gases out. The downside to this, is you still have small amounts of crankcase gases returning into the intake. This causes slight changes in the Air/Fuel Ratio, and also gives the incoming air a new path to take, causing turbulence in the air system that does not offer a smooth flow.
I am currently working on an alternative to these two styles of venting, similar to a Top Fuel Dragster. They have a setup where the crankcase is vented into the exhaust. The way this works is that the exhaust creates a venturi effect (similar to a carburetor), which pulls the fumes from the crankcase into the exhaust stream. The higher the rpm, the faster the exhaust will flow, and the more vacuum will be applied to the crankcase. At higher RPMs you will get more blow-by and this is compensated by higher vacuum. The problem with doing this on our systems is that we do not run the same exhaust as Top Fuel cars. They make so much power they do not need much exhaust tuning to induce flow, they can use atmospheric pressure at the exhaust to flow outwardly, whereas our cars need back-pressure to ensure a low pressure is created within the headers to pull the exhaust out of the engine. Due to this back-pressure, the same venting system may not work on our exhaust, as the exhaust does not create constant flow.
I will do some more research and see if I can come up with a universal solution, but for now I would say if you are running N/A on stock compression, remove the PCV and install a breather (add a catch can if you like). If you are running a turbo, leave the PCV in place (or get an adjustable PCV for high performance applications) and install a catch can between the PCV and the intake. You will need the intake vacuum on a turbo car to pull the crank gases out.