Easiest (cheapest) to replace the entire instrument cluster with a used one. Check out
http://www.car-part.com under "Instrument Cluster or "Speedometer". You should probably stick with a 96 because of the OBDII, but I'm not sure it matters whether it's Federal or California model. Yours is NOT an ACTSUS (active suspension) model. And I don't think you have TCS (traction control) either (yours is NOT a Q45t, right?).
So you need one for/from a non-TCS, non-ACTSUS model.