gawdzilla
Online
1665 posts
none
9-18-2004
|
the dealer ones (infiniti q45, forget which cylinders. something like 1 and 5 but don't quote me on that) are a little over $100 a piece. added up, that's $600 for new oem.splitfires are 450-500, and IMO are no WORSE than oem. it is arguable whether or not they are much better. but worst case, you are getting a new set of coils vs. whatever old crap came with your motor. i am running them now and they are okay. i assume you tried putting in new plugs and regapping? plugs foul easy and even easier with a misfiring system. sounds like you might also have a boost leak. is your car missing really bad or is it just not pulling hard? if it runs smooth and just doesn't pull you probably have a boost leak or your tune is out.
Just your average dreamer looking for a 240
 http://forums.racebread.com
|
craz4240
Offline
578 posts
1995 240sx w/rb20det
Waverley NS
9-13-2006
|
| « Re: (gawdzilla) | 9:26 AM 7/20/2008 |
|
Why not do a GNX coil retrofit??Is your motor series 1 or 2???
|
gawdzilla
Online
1665 posts
none
9-18-2004
|
| « Re: (craz4240) | 9:32 AM 7/20/2008 |
|
| Quote, originally posted by craz4240 » | Why not do a GNX coil retrofit??
|
because not everyone wants to go backwards in technology from coil on plug to wasted spark, plug wires, and a big box you need to find somewhere to hide in your engine bay.
|
240z4u

Offline
1105 posts
Madison Wi
2-21-2005
|
| « Re: (gawdzilla) | 9:45 AM 7/20/2008 |
|
I have to say, I find it interesting that everyone loves the buick V6 coil conversion. Don't church it up, its not a "GNX" or even "GN" coil set. Its the same coilset that comes on the n/a crapwagons too. Its a fine basic solution yes. The buick guys have spark problems with those coilpacks too. I had one (a GN).You can get a coil similar to the buick coil from summit that will allow you to do a non-wasted spark setup. I forget the real name, sorry. Also gawdzilla, I really don't agree with your suggestion that you are going backwards in technology by going to a setup that is not coil on plug. Granted 80s buick technology is old. Evan
RB25DET SII, T3/T04E, Power FC, 650cc injectors, new pump, aeromotive FPR, 3" dp/exhaust. FMIC, Z32 maf, Home Depot MBC, Tial external gate, forge motorsports BOV, Methanol injection, custom intake manifold, modded and coated stock exhaust manifold.
|
gawdzilla
Online
1665 posts
none
9-18-2004
|
i'm not saying the wasted spark technology won't work. carbs work too and also work great. my view of technology tends to follow what current production cars are doing. most are direct ignition now... so i would say wasted spark is going backwards.
|
rb25drag

Offline
972 posts
1990 240sx
Springcity tn
9-24-2007
|
| « Re: (gawdzilla) | 10:17 AM 7/20/2008 |
|
Well, here is how it started. It first started when I went from 1st to 2nd gear it totally dropped 1-2 cyl for about 5 seconds then picked back up and ran fine. It only done it when I shifted and it dropped RPM's.Then the more I ran the car it got to were it started misfiring anything above 5,000RPM's. On my last pass of the night it would not even rev over 5,000 While on WOT, and the A/F readings on my wideband went to 9.0 Which is Pig rich and it was holding 15lbs of boost, Not dropping off. I know there is no boost leaks and I also no its not a spark plug foul, It Revs Fine and idles good, no missing like a fouled plug would cause. I pulled the plugs, They were Gray looking which seemed to be not too rich and not too lean, The Gaps are .022 just as I set them. I have a s2 motor, Which if I went to the Buick coils I would have to buy a igniter and hack my harness, Which I don't really wanna do. I would rather just buy what fits and plugs in and go. Im also afraid of the buick coil not working with my launch control which I just spent 300$ on. Im almost 100% my coils are getting weak. I don't think they have been in the greatest shape from day 1, I just didn't wanna spend more $ than I had too. I mean, Something is Def screwed, I went from a 7.80@91 in the 1/8th to 10.02 @ 67, on the same tune.
|
crccustoms
Offline
9 posts
Sunbury Ohio
3-3-2008
|
| « Re: Rb25det Coil replacement Debate!! (rb25drag) | 11:03 AM 7/20/2008 |
|
i really suggest you run an ignition box like msd's dis with good coils and wires because the potential output of that setup beats anything ive seen from a coil on plug setup, and if your serious into drag racing you've probably seen them, now ive heard of people using the summit part (Summit SUM-850592-1) which is a coil on plug setup for ford vehicles but im afraid i cannot offer much information on that swap, and if your afraid to revert to the plug wire setup and think the coil over plug setup is better, theres alot of racing crews from drag racing to circle tracks that still trust the plug wire setup, theres not really that much resistance compared to the plug over coil setup, and you'll have a much more reliable ignition system
|
rudedrift

Offline
18 posts
240sx
buffalo ny
1-14-2006
|
i have an rb25 sII and ever since i turned up the boost to 10psi with an rb20 wastegate i've had the same problems. changed coil packs and plugs and all that. i think i'm goin to run the gm set-up.

|
Blown240sx
Offline
1725 posts
1996 240sx
Bowling Green KY
4-21-2005
|
| « Re: (rudedrift) | 11:42 AM 7/20/2008 |
|
IF you want a strong setup we ran 6 MSD SS blaster coils on my friends 400 whp RB and the spark output puts any of the factory or aftermarket replacments to shame and cost about the same.. How to....
take your coils out and pull out the coil harness where its easy to see. Mark each of the center wires they should be some combination of red/xxxx another color. Number them so you will remember what cylinder they fire. Start at the ignitor and de loom the harness towards the coils. You will have 3 wires to each coil. 1 power, 1 constant ground, and 1 switch ground from the Ignitor. The factory ground going to each coil will not be used. Take the factory power and either daisy chain it across all the MSD coils or use it as a switch 12v for a thicker Relayed system. Recommended We used 10 gauge wire and a high amp replay since the factory wire is thinner gauge. You can use the factory power wire to switch your relay. Now run your power, daisy chaining it off every coil to (+) side on the coil. Now for the switch. Youll need to extend all the wires coming from the ignitor. The ignitor is a large relay essentially and it sends ground pulse. Run a lead to each coil in the order you marked before removing the harness. This goes to the (-) negative side of the coil. Then use the boot kit they come with and make your wires and mount the coils somewhere and fire it up.
1990 240sx (RIP) 1989 240sx (sold) 1996 240sx 408ci V8 (sold) 1972 Datsun 240z LS1-T project (in progress)
|
Largekid

Offline
135 posts
'95 240SX
Indianapolis IN
6-23-2003
|
| « Re: (Blown240sx) | 11:48 AM 7/20/2008 |
|
| Quote, originally posted by Blown240sx » | | IF you want a strong setup we ran 6 MSD SS blaster coils on my friends 400 whp RB and the spark output puts any of the factory or aftermarket replacments to shame and cost about the same.. How to....
take your coils out and pull out the coil harness where its easy to see. Mark each of the center wires they should be some combination of red/xxxx another color. Number them so you will remember what cylinder they fire. Start at the ignitor and de loom the harness towards the coils. You will have 3 wires to each coil. 1 power, 1 constant ground, and 1 switch ground from the Ignitor. The factory ground going to each coil will not be used. Take the factory power and either daisy chain it across all the MSD coils or use it as a switch 12v for a thicker Relayed system. Recommended We used 10 gauge wire and a high amp replay since the factory wire is thinner gauge. You can use the factory power wire to switch your relay. Now run your power, daisy chaining it off every coil to (+) side on the coil. Now for the switch. Youll need to extend all the wires coming from the ignitor. The ignitor is a large relay essentially and it sends ground pulse. Run a lead to each coil in the order you marked before removing the harness. This goes to the (-) negative side of the coil. Then use the boot kit they come with and make your wires and mount the coils somewhere and fire it up. |
Yes, I own that car now, and have no problems w/ it whatsoever...if you need me to help out anyway with getting this setup to work for you, let me know...i'll help where I can  edit...didn't see the pictures, but thats my engine bay in the pics he posted lol

|
Blown240sx
Offline
1725 posts
1996 240sx
Bowling Green KY
4-21-2005
|
| « Re: (Largekid) | 11:53 AM 7/20/2008 |
|
Me and my friend you bought it from did that install.
|
rudedrift

Offline
18 posts
240sx
buffalo ny
1-14-2006
|
sweetness. that's whats up. i'm though with factory coilcraps
|
rb25drag

Offline
972 posts
1990 240sx
Springcity tn
9-24-2007
|
| « Re: (Blown240sx) | 12:11 PM 7/20/2008 |
|
I really like that MSD setup, Thats Clean!!My only question is on a SII we don't have ignitors. Is this a problem running that setup?
|
Carl H
Bio-less Moderator

Offline
3816 posts
1995 240SX SE
charlotte nc
8-4-2003
|
or how bout install a quest alternator because the stock 80a pos cant keep up with the amp draw from your efans and thus killing spark.
SHift_BOOM. Damnit. Doing an RB2X swap and scared of the wiring? Check out my thread in the RB section. Now offering VH and SR/KA/CA conversions!
|
rb25drag

Offline
972 posts
1990 240sx
Springcity tn
9-24-2007
|
| « Re: (Carl H) | 12:21 PM 7/20/2008 |
|
I installed the quest and it worked for about 1 day and died!! Lost 80$ on the deal, The stock alternator is doing fine. So No need to change something thats not broke, I didn't notice any difference with the quest either.
|
Coolwhip
NICO Sponsor

Offline
1749 posts
Orlando Florida
2-6-2004
|
| « Re: (rb25drag) | 2:09 PM 7/20/2008 |
|
I have a set of S2 coils for sale. As well, I'm having a shipment of upgraded coil units that I'll start distributing pretty soon. Once I have a personal review on a set, I'll let you know. But for a set that perform just as well as any spitfire or any direct ignition unit and such will only set you back $499 for a set.
Treasurer of the NRRBA - Non-Running RB Association Join today! Temporary and Lifetime memberships available. Send your dues to me.
 "Parts for a complete and balanced engine"
|
rb25drag

Offline
972 posts
1990 240sx
Springcity tn
9-24-2007
|
| « Re: (Coolwhip) | 2:41 PM 7/20/2008 |
|
Sweet, How long will it be before you get the upgraded coils?
|
craz4240
Offline
578 posts
1995 240sx w/rb20det
Waverley NS
9-13-2006
|
| « Re: (gawdzilla) | 2:54 PM 7/20/2008 |
|
| Quote, originally posted by gawdzilla » | because not everyone wants to go backwards in technology from coil on plug to wasted spark, plug wires, and a big box you need to find somewhere to hide in your engine bay. |
Yeah it kindof is but it works equally as good as stock and is ALOT cheaper to replace when the time comes.
|
Blown240sx
Offline
1725 posts
1996 240sx
Bowling Green KY
4-21-2005
|
| « Re: (craz4240) | 3:53 PM 7/20/2008 |
|
The S2 should work the same. Since they still send a signal directly to each coil. It should work the same. All ignition systems like this are switch ground.
|
crccustoms
Offline
9 posts
Sunbury Ohio
3-3-2008
|
| « Re: (Blown240sx) | 7:08 PM 7/20/2008 |
|
good clean setup blown240, and i agree you'll end up spending as much or more with the stock style coils than the msd setup with 8mm that can be achieved for around $350 from summit, and if you need more spark due to higher compression $400 buys you higher output coils and 10 mm wires, the summit (sum-850500m) coils are rated at 51,000v and have enough power to fire the discovery space shuttle to the next galaxy, there $50 a piece at summit, $75-100 for a good set of wires and your set, and you would go about hooking up that setup the same way as the msd, negative being the trigger, which comes from the harness that your stock setup uses
|
240z4u

Offline
1105 posts
Madison Wi
2-21-2005
|
| « Re: (crccustoms) | 8:02 PM 7/20/2008 |
|
Coil on plug is fine when its not a total cooker under the hood. I really think thats what helps lead to the demise of the stock coils. I have wondered forever if having a phonelic coilpack bracket made would help keep them cooler. You would have to run ground straps from the coil body to the valvecover though. Anyway, the MSD setup looks pretty good too. Evan
|
Cjmartz2k

Online
484 posts
'92 Skyline w/RB25 & Holset HX40
Japan
5-19-2007
|
| « Re: (240z4u) | 9:39 PM 7/20/2008 |
|
Have you tried cleaning the contact inside it i.e. popping off the boot, removing the spring, and sticking a dremel down in there to remove the crap that builds up? Just hit it until it looks like shiny brass down inside the coil pack and give it a shot. Mine sucked under 22psi until I did that, and now they are handling 26psi with no problems.
|
Blown240sx
Offline
1725 posts
1996 240sx
Bowling Green KY
4-21-2005
|
| « Re: (crccustoms) | 1:02 AM 7/21/2008 |
|
| Quote, originally posted by crccustoms » | good clean setup blown240, and i agree you'll end up spending as much or more with the stock style coils than the msd setup with 8mm that can be achieved for around $350 from summit, and if you need more spark due to higher compression $400 buys you higher output coils and 10 mm wires, the summit (sum-850500m) coils are rated at 51,000v and have enough power to fire the discovery space shuttle to the next galaxy, there $50 a piece at summit, $75-100 for a good set of wires and your set, and you would go about hooking up that setup the same way as the msd, negative being the trigger, which comes from the harness that your stock setup uses |
I cant take much credit since the previous owner (brandon) did the wiring but I fully understand how it was done and how it works.
|
gawdzilla
Online
1665 posts
none
9-18-2004
|
| « Re: (rb25drag) | 7:01 AM 7/21/2008 |
|
| Quote, originally posted by rb25drag » | | Well, here is how it started. It first started when I went from 1st to 2nd gear it totally dropped 1-2 cyl for about 5 seconds then picked back up and ran fine. It only done it when I shifted and it dropped RPM's. Then the more I ran the car it got to were it started misfiring anything above 5,000RPM's. On my last pass of the night it would not even rev over 5,000 While on WOT, and the A/F readings on my wideband went to 9.0 Which is Pig rich and it was holding 15lbs of boost, Not dropping off. I know there is no boost leaks and I also no its not a spark plug foul, It Revs Fine and idles good, no missing like a fouled plug would cause. I pulled the plugs, They were Gray looking which seemed to be not too rich and not too lean, The Gaps are .022 just as I set them. I have a s2 motor, Which if I went to the Buick coils I would have to buy a igniter and hack my harness, Which I don't really wanna do. I would rather just buy what fits and plugs in and go. Im also afraid of the buick coil not working with my launch control which I just spent 300$ on. Im almost 100% my coils are getting weak. I don't think they have been in the greatest shape from day 1, I just didn't wanna spend more $ than I had too. I mean, Something is Def screwed, I went from a 7.80@91 in the 1/8th to 10.02 @ 67, on the same tune.
|
your wideband is going to show false richness if you are misfiring. there is unburnt fuel that is coming out of your exhaust each time you miss a spark. that is probably why your wideband is showing rich.did you try putting in new plugs? i always keep a spare set in my toolbox now. in my experience, once plugs have seen a bit of missing (or poor tune), they don't perform nearly as well as a new set. i have tried torching the plugs to clean them up too. if you're running colder plugs, they will foul easier too. just grab a fresh set to rule out the plugs themselves. they're what? $1.50 a piece?
|
Carl H
Bio-less Moderator

Offline
3816 posts
1995 240SX SE
charlotte nc
8-4-2003
|
i still say its a power issue...stock coils will light off some pretty intense charge pressures... if you have a pfc check out the battery voltage on full boost with the fans on, anything less than 13.8v will cause misfires.
|
Blown240sx
Offline
1725 posts
1996 240sx
Bowling Green KY
4-21-2005
|
| « Re: (Carl H) | 9:50 AM 7/21/2008 |
|
Yea but the power fc has maps in it that will lower everything if that occurs. It has maps for low voltage compared to the ignition.
|
Carl H
Bio-less Moderator

Offline
3816 posts
1995 240SX SE
charlotte nc
8-4-2003
|
true but in reality they dont work well, trust me i had a 25pfc on my 20 for a hot second there and it would quite literaly poop out a brick when voltages would drop below 13.5 or so...ended up fitting a quest alternator and that problem dissapeared.
|
rb25drag

Offline
972 posts
1990 240sx
Springcity tn
9-24-2007
|
| « Re: (Carl H) | 2:39 PM 7/21/2008 |
|
I haven't tried to clean the coils yet. Ill def look into that. I do have a new set of plugs but have not tried them yet. I got busy and didn't have time to throw them in. I will spend more time on it this weekend.I really don't think its electrical, Its def something with the spark. I am running a # 4 cold plug. Always had great results on this motor with it. Been running those kind for 2 years. I have about 26 track passes on these plugs.
|
Carl H
Bio-less Moderator

Offline
3816 posts
1995 240SX SE
charlotte nc
8-4-2003
|
| « Re: (rb25drag) | 4:31 PM 7/21/2008 |
|
rotfl. classic.
| Quote, originally posted by rb25drag » | I really don't think its electrical, Its def something with the spark.
|
Ive tried to help push you in the right direction man but if you dont want to listen then thats cool too, i think that you fail to see that an 80a alternator cannot provide power to a car that has to run high amperage drawing electric fans, provide power to 6 coils which are individualy fired as well as 6 injectors all while powering the car's electronics and interior. Stick a multimeter on the battery terminals and run leads into the cabin and see what voltage looks like with everything on and running, i bet it will be low 13's at best...most likely high 12's.
|
rb25drag

Offline
972 posts
1990 240sx
Springcity tn
9-24-2007
|
| « Re: (Carl H) | 5:23 PM 7/21/2008 |
|
By all means man I do take your advice and I do look at everything that is suggested. I have a volt gauge hooked up to my solenoid that runs all my electronics, Which is the furthest from my alternator. It reads 13.8-14.0 Even with my electric fans on. Along with everything else I run. Ill look at it a little closer, But im just not seeing it as a problem. Its ran on that same system for a few years now. I personally think the misfiring of the coils on my launches has either killed my coils or my plugs. Its just weird that it will start Idle and rev free fine just like always. But in my theory of a weak coil it will do this and when I get into High boost its blowing my Spark out of the plugs causing the misfire. Thats the only thing I can think of. Another reason I think they are weak is due to I had to run my spark plug gap so small .022 after raising my boost from 10-15lbs, it wouldn't stop misfiring until I changed the spark plug gap. Is there a Real way to test the coils?
|
d356bud

Offline
123 posts
Towanda PA
5-20-2007
|
I've been thinking about a new coil setup since one of my coils took a crap on me. I tested mine by triggering the coil myself and comparing the gap at which the spark stopped jumping and compared it to a known good coil. That told me whether the coil was weak or not and whether the coil worked. I thought about using three GM DIS coils that I have laying around. Sorry to thread jack but has anyone had problems using these, for example, a burnt up ignitor or anything like that?
__________________________________________________ 1990 s13(fastback) powered by a RB25DET
|
WhatsADSM

Offline
154 posts
1998 240sx
Milwaukee WI
6-10-2005
|
While we are on the topic, figured I would cross post to my thread about my LS2/LS7 coil swap, in case someone runs into this thread while searching: http://forums.nicoclub.com/zerothread/353832
|
rb25drag

Offline
972 posts
1990 240sx
Springcity tn
9-24-2007
|
| « Re: (WhatsADSM) | 6:15 PM 7/22/2008 |
|
Well im glad there is Several alternative options out there!! Everyones setup is sweet!! Good job by everyone, Im Really interested in that MSD tho, Im really worried about my Launch Control working. Does anyone have any experience with the Gizzmo launch interface on a different coil setup?
|
WhatsADSM

Offline
154 posts
1998 240sx
Milwaukee WI
6-10-2005
|
| « Re: (rb25drag) | 6:36 PM 7/22/2008 |
|
| Quote, originally posted by rb25drag » | | Well im glad there is Several alternative options out there!! Everyones setup is sweet!! Good job by everyone, Im Really interested in that MSD tho, Im really worried about my Launch Control working. Does anyone have any experience with the Gizzmo launch interface on a different coil setup? |
How does the Gizzmo install? I take it you attach it to the input side of the ignitor? And you install with all 6 trigger wires right? If so it will work fine if you use the blaster coils listed above. As a side note. How much did you pay for that gizzmo launch control? I could probably make those things for people for pretty cheap if there was a demand... shift light and all
|
gawdzilla
Online
1665 posts
none
9-18-2004
|
| « Re: (WhatsADSM) | 7:03 AM 7/23/2008 |
|
| Quote, originally posted by WhatsADSM » | How does the Gizzmo install? I take it you attach it to the input side of the ignitor? And you install with all 6 trigger wires right? If so it will work fine if you use the blaster coils listed above. As a side note. How much did you pay for that gizzmo launch control? I could probably make those things for people for pretty cheap if there was a demand... shift light and all |
might not even be that complicated, depending if its a quality one or not. i know the cheaper ones like bee-r only have 4 wires i think. 2 inputs from CAS and +, -.
|
dftsilvia

Offline
124 posts
s14
buffalo n.y.
12-28-2006
|
| « Re: (gawdzilla) | 7:33 AM 7/23/2008 |
|
i wonder why this subject is so hit and miss with the rb. i mean some people run stock coils and have no problems at all even with highly modded motors, and other people have trouble with all stock motors. i bet it doesnt help that these engines sit around on pallets and in the weather at the junk yards. im almost willing to bet that as soon as these coils see any kind of water they are shot. i wonder if the wire harness just doesnt use big enough gauge wire??what are guys doing over in the rising sun?? everytime i see a jap rb they are running stock coilpacks. it seems to work for them. is there some sort of voltage stabilizer that is maybe on the car but when we get the engines over here we dont get them with motor sets???? all i know is i hope i dont run into this one the neo is up and running lol
Driftset SuiSlide Sawce Money
|
rudedrift

Offline
18 posts
240sx
buffalo ny
1-14-2006
|
me too. we'll ahve two farting and poopin rb's. and the hood brothas will smoke us with they rb20's!!!
|
rb25drag

Offline
972 posts
1990 240sx
Springcity tn
9-24-2007
|
| « Re: (WhatsADSM) | 2:07 PM 7/23/2008 |
|
| Quote, originally posted by WhatsADSM » | How does the Gizzmo install? I take it you attach it to the input side of the ignitor? And you install with all 6 trigger wires right? If so it will work fine if you use the blaster coils listed above. As a side note. How much did you pay for that gizzmo launch control? I could probably make those things for people for pretty cheap if there was a demand... shift light and all |
The Gizzmo has 16 wires, 6 input on coil signal to ECU and 6 output to coils from gizzmo, 1 ground, 1 power, and 2 tach signals, one from ECU to unit and one from unit to Shift light. Nothing hooks to the CAS. Im assuming it will work also, I just don't wanna buy then find out It won't work. I know the Gizzmo works with some coils and some it does not. Ill have to try and find out what it won't work with.
|
rb25drag

Offline
972 posts
1990 240sx
Springcity tn
9-24-2007
|
| « Re: (rb25drag) | 6:31 PM 7/23/2008 |
|
Well I got a few moments to spend with it today. Here is what i found. I changed Spark Plugs, Took the coils apart, They was Corroded, Cleaned them, And took a separate spark plug and seen how they fire. Every coil Looks really weak, Its more of a White spark, Not blue at all, Just seems Really weak looking to me. But after all that took the car for a ride, Its fine at low RPMs and Low throttle, Anything over 1/4 just chokes it to its death. The A/F readings Go from Cruising at 14.1 to half throttle 10.0 to Full throttle 9.0 A/F readings. Just gets pig rich. So Im sure the coils are shot. I don't know what else to test. Also Carl H, I looked at my Volt gauge Closely, it runs about 14.4- 14.7 without the electric fans on. When I hit the Switch it goes to about 14.4 and stays there. So Im also ruling out Alternator. Any other suggestions before I go buying coils?
|
| First 1 2 > Last |