EniGmA1987 wrote:The00Dustin wrote:I thought there was a post about gearing once upon a time and the 7 speeds had the same (or very close to the same) final drive ratios as the 5 speeds they replaced.
The 2009 with 7 speed has a 7th gear ratio of:
Seventh Gear Ratio (:1) 0.77
Final Drive Axle Ratio (:1) 3.35
Whereas the 2006 (non-AWD) is:
Fifth Gear Ratio (:1): 0.84
Final Drive Axle Ratio (:1): 3.54
2006 (AWD):
Fifth Gear Ratio (:1): 0.84
Final Drive Axle Ratio (:1): 3.69
It's interesting to see that there's not THAT much of a difference in the top-gear ratios and final drive ratios between the 7-speed auto and the 5-speed auto. I figured their would of been a bigger difference since the 7-speed seems to be geared for primarily fuel economy over performance which is why the 7-speed models are supposed to be about the same in 0-60 and 1/4 mile times when compared to the older 5-speed models in the 2008 G37 and 2009 G37 (I used the G37 as an example because all other factors were equal except for the transmissions).
I definitely do understand why Infiniti used a 3.54 and 3.69 final-drive ratio for the M35 and M35x, this is clearly a
performance-luxury
sports sedan that is geared for sporty/aggressive driving over merely soft cushy luxury and fuel economy, but I just don't understand why they had to use such a short 0.84 5th gear ratio. They could of kept the aggressive final-drive ratios the same while just simply making the 5th gear ratio a little taller since it's the overdrive gear anyway, something like maybe 0.75, and it would of lowered the highway rpms down some which would ultimately make 5th a more suitable overdrive gear which would increase highway fuel economy and lower engine/exhaust noise at highway speeds with a very minimal loss in acceleration and performance, especially considering that 5th gear isn't really used for high acceleration anyway.
Overdrive should be a REAL overdrive gear ratio, especially when you have less than 6 gears in your transmission. The overdrive gear is supposed to be designed for maximum highway fuel economy and reduced engine/exhaust noise at highway speeds as opposed to high acceleration and performance, therefore it doesn't need to be a short and aggressive gear ratio because in the 5-speed auto you have 4 other well-spaced gear ratios for good acceleration and overall performance to get you up to the higher speeds, but the overdrive top-gear ratio of a transmission should be a little taller so that you get the most fuel economy possible on the highway and the lowest engine/exhaust noise to make a comfortable and relaxed highway ride.
Although I'm not really complaining about it, I do love my M35x, and the highway rpms aren't really that high especially compared to some other sporty performance cars out there, I'm around 2500rpms or so at 65 mph which is a standard highway cruising speed in the area I live in NY, and actually I think the Jatco RE5R05A 5-speed auto in this car is probably one of the best 5-speed automatics that was ever made and it was definitely ahead of it's time in design and technology, and I also do think that 1st, 2nd, 3rd, and 4th gear ratios are VERY well-spaced with an overall very good power/acceleration spread, but I just think that if they had used an overdrive gear ratio of around 0.75 for 5th gear it would have helped with overally highway fuel economy without really sacrificing the powerful and sporty acceleration and performance that these cars are well-known for. Just my two cents.