Post by
float_6969 »
https://forums.nicoclub.com/float-6969-u780.html
Tue Jun 10, 2014 7:18 pm
There's more pressure on the "pipe 1" that you illustrated, than the way you initially talked about, and the last two pictures you posted.
Let me give you a quick rundown on what's going on here.
Turbo spins because of heat and pressure in the exhaust. Spinning turbo SUCKS air in THROUGH the AIR FILTER, into the MAFS, and then into the inlet of the TURBO. Then the air is PRESSURIZED. During the pressurization it's also HEATED. The HOT, PRESSURIZED AIR LEAVES the turbo and goes INTO the INTERCOOLER. There it is COOLED. There is also a slight DROP in pressure (varies, but usually 2-5psi in an air-to-air intercooler) The COLD air is then fed INTO the THROTTLE BODY.
There are two trains of thought behind the BOV/Recirc Valve placement.
The first is to place the valve as close to the throttle body so that the pressure wave that occurs when the throttle is shut (which also originates at the throttle body) is relieved near the source. This is supposed to be easier on the turbo. If you're venting then this is fine and there is no real drawback, other than the fact that you vented nicely cooled air into the engine bay, which increases thermal load on the intercooler system. The load isn't great, but it's there.
The second is to place it on the hot pipe. The reason for this is that it's much easier from a plumbing standpoint, and you're not venting/recirculating cooled air. Supposedly there is a greater risk for throttle closed compressor surge, which is hard on the turbo, but to be honest, I have yet to see that demonstrated/proved.
So all of that being said, When I had a MAFS and was recirculating, I had it on the hot pipe. The piping was simple and short and I ran 15psi on an SR T25 and never had any issues. I've also ran recirculated on the cold side with an S15 SR T28 at 18psi and I didn't see any difference. My last setup was vented on the cold pipe. I did this for simplicities sake. My hot pipe was REALLY short and I didn't have much room for a BOV. When I re-do my intercooler piping again, I'm going to put the valve on the hot pipe and have it vented. I have a standalone with a MAP, so I don't have to worry about off-throttle stumble.
Put it on the hot pipe. It will work fine, and you won't have any issues. Trust me. I've done it both ways and there is no noticeable gain from the effort of putting it on the cold pipe.