Matic J tranny fluid will be no more! Auto Trans people Read!!

The G-Series Tuning Forum is the place to discuss G35/G37 performance modifications and mechanical repair.
kmech_7
Posts: 322
Joined: Fri Jan 19, 2007 7:16 pm
Car: 2003 Infiniti G35 coupe (Skyline) Vortech Supercharged Jul 08 ROTM
Contact:

Post

here is a sample:

Thank you for contacting Castrol North America.

Castrol Multi-Vehicle ATF provides customers with a single ATF product that meets multiple specifications.

Multi-Vehicle ATF provides the following benefits:- Enhanced friction durability for smooth transmission operation- Exceptional high temperature protection to effectively resist fluid oxidation- Superb low temperature fluidity for cold weather shifting.

Castrol Multi-Vehicle ATF is recommended for use for the followingspecifications:

1. ATF+, ATF+2, ATF+2 Type 71762. Mitsubishi Diamond SP-II and SP-III3. ATF+3, ATF+44. Nissan Matic-D and Matic-J5. BMW LT71141 and LA26346. Toyota Type T, T-III and T-IV7. Dexron, Dexron-II, Dexron-III and Dexron-IID8. Voith 55.6335.32 (G607)9. Honda ATF-Z1 (except CVTs)10. Volvo (except 5-speed)11. MAN 339F12. ZF TE-ML 14B and TE-ML 16L

This product is only available through dealerships and Oil Change locations featuring Castrol and not through Castrol retailers.

Than you for your interest in Castrol, The Technology Leader!

Castrol Consumer Relations

also:

Genuine NISSAN ATF Matic Fluid J or exact equivalent.Using A/T fluid other than NISSAN Genuine ATF Matic Fluid J or exact equivalent will cause deterioration in driveability and A/T durability, and may damage the A/T, which is not covered by the NISSAN new vehicle limited warranty. Currently available exact equivalents to NISSAN Genuine ATF Matic Fluid J are Castrol Transmax J or IDEMITSU ATF HP

and:

Pennzoil® Multi-Vehicle ATF is a special blend of high-quality mineral base stocks with an advanced additive system for automatic and powershift transmissions. It meets the requirements of transmissions requiring DEXRON® -III, MERCON®, MERCON® V and Allison C-4 fluid. In addition, Pennzoil® Multi-Vehicle ATF is recommended by Pennzoil® for Chrysler automatic transmissions and can function as a Caterpillar TO-2 lubricant. Pennzoil® Multi-Vehicle ATF is formulated to provide protection that meets or exceeds the highest quality standards in the industry.

PENNZOIL® MULTI-VEHICLE ATF is suitable for use in applications requiring:

DEXRON®, DEXRON®-II, DEXRON®-III. MERCON®, MERCON® V. Chrysler/Dodge/Jeep/Plymouth (except NAG1 that requires Shell 3403 ATF). Allison C-4. Toyota T, T-III, T-IV. Honda Premium Formula ATF, ATF-Z1 (except in CVTs). Mitsubishi/Kia/Hyundai SP, SP-II, SP-III. Nissan Matic -D, Nissan Matic-J. BMW LA2634, LT71141.

Not for use in vehicles requiring Type F, DEXRON®-VI, MERCON® SP, Full Synthetic MERCON®, Nissan Matic K, Toyota/Lexus WS, Mercedes Benz 3403-M115, BMW 1375.4, or Volvo 1161540-8. Also not for use for CVT. Check owner's manual and/or dipstick for exact specification.



User avatar
SteveTheTech
Posts: 4505
Joined: Sat Aug 16, 2008 3:20 pm
Car: 15 Sentra SR
12 G37x Coupe
-Formerly-
05 Mazda 6 L3 Sport, 95 J30, 94 D22
Location: Chantilly, Va

Post

Will they warranty your transmission if you use that? I just don't get why you would cheap out on something like this? It's like putting the cheapest tires and brakes on your car, I would personally not jeopardize my families safety with something that may cause me to get stuck, when there is something that is designed for it. Save your pennies and do the job right.

I'm sure there are only a few fluid characteristics that work well for the demanding needs of an automatic transmission. I would personally give you a 3 of 5 for your Googling skills. Of course you loose a few points for copy pasting product marketing.

The reason I am leaning the other way is from what I have seen. I get to see them when people take their cars elsewhere. Now they feel a slipping (especially during the 2/3 shift under normal to moderate throttle input) or erratic TCC operation due to a loss of fluid pressure during extended TCC duty cycles.

User avatar
SteveTheTech
Posts: 4505
Joined: Sat Aug 16, 2008 3:20 pm
Car: 15 Sentra SR
12 G37x Coupe
-Formerly-
05 Mazda 6 L3 Sport, 95 J30, 94 D22
Location: Chantilly, Va

Post

Sentientbydesign wrote:You pissed him off enough to call me earlier...We spoke about him doing a write up for a custom title and I suggested a "great" title...Not safe for the kiddies eyes.

User avatar
Poyzinous
Posts: 2859
Joined: Mon Feb 02, 2009 9:56 am
Car: 2004 G35x Premium 1976 Classic Red 36 inch #18 Radio Flyer Wagon...
Location: Latitude 38.8* N, Longitude 77.1* W

Post

How very inappropriate, thank you. I needed that.

kmech_7
Posts: 322
Joined: Fri Jan 19, 2007 7:16 pm
Car: 2003 Infiniti G35 coupe (Skyline) Vortech Supercharged Jul 08 ROTM
Contact:

Post

SteveTheTech wrote:Will they warranty your transmission if you use that? I just don't get why you would cheap out on something like this? It's like putting the cheapest tires and brakes on your car, I would personally not jeopardize my families safety with something that may cause me to get stuck, when there is something that is designed for it. Save your pennies and do the job right.

I'm sure there are only a few fluid characteristics that work well for the demanding needs of an automatic transmission. I would personally give you a 3 of 5 for your Googling skills. Of course you loose a few points for copy pasting product marketing.

The reason I am leaning the other way is from what I have seen. I get to see them when people take their cars elsewhere. Now they feel a slipping (especially during the 2/3 shift under normal to moderate throttle input) or erratic TCC operation due to a loss of fluid pressure during extended TCC duty cycles.
I doint understand how you think it is cheaping out on something like this. The original fluid nissan used for its matic-j was made by castrol. So does this mean if I put the castrol in my car I am cheaping out? NO. This just means that I dont feel the need to pay for an item that has been marked-up to buy through a dealer to give me that little butterfly feeling in my tummy knowing I got it from a dealer so it must be right. I dont know how many times I can say this but....THE DEALER IS NOT ALWAYS RIGHT!

I have done a lot of things to my car and just because I dont use Matic-j from nissan doesnt make me wrong. I also do have a fully built tranny that is able to withstand 800whp. How many of you have that? Im pretty sure once you hit 400whp you will need a new one. I know, this built one is #3. The other 2 were stock auto trans with matic j only. I also dont use majik pixi dust oil from nissan. does this also make me wrong? I do use Royal Purple 10w-30. I also have many mods done to my car as you can check by my sig(I cant fit them all in).

I guess the point I'm trying to make is this-"Just because the dealer wants you to believe something doesnt make it true. If I were to stick to stock rims and tires, also dealer prescribed, I would have no traction and I wouldnt be at the race track on my 285/45-17 slicks either. I dont want to here that 'that's different'. Guess what-ITS NOT."

User avatar
SteveTheTech
Posts: 4505
Joined: Sat Aug 16, 2008 3:20 pm
Car: 15 Sentra SR
12 G37x Coupe
-Formerly-
05 Mazda 6 L3 Sport, 95 J30, 94 D22
Location: Chantilly, Va

Post

kmech_7 wrote:THE DEALER IS NOT ALWAYS RIGHT!
Nor are random people on the internet. I have done lots of things to lots or peoples cars. WTF is your point?

The great thing about America is you can do whatever the hell you want to your car, by all means go on be fast and or furious. I lack the motivation and patience to pursue this further.

This is turning into a "Driver" worthy thread.

User avatar
Sentientbydesign
Posts: 6768
Joined: Wed Feb 02, 2005 8:21 am
Car: 03 Evo VIII - 330 AWHP
05 Subaru Legacy GT Stg 2 - Sold
05 G35 6MT Coupe - 278 WHP - Sold
04 WW Evo VIII - 302 AWHP - Ex's
96 I30 - Sold
Contact:

Post

Disclaimer to all non-Nissan employees:

The guys that work at Nissan/Infiniti have either been trained, have experienced, or are simply insuring business for themselves.

Does that mean they are brainwashed, dumb, sneaky? Not necessarily, it could be any one of those, or they could genuinely believe that the OEM design was perfect.

On the flip side, there were NUMEROUS design flaws on the G and Z that were gradually improved upon or completely scrapped and redesigned in 07/08. As it is, Nissan screwed up on the VQ37HR so... yeah.

Take it as you will. I think we've all come to the conclusion that Matic-J/S is NOT the same as Dexron III, however you can get the same fluid for less if you can find out who else is bottling it

kmech_7
Posts: 322
Joined: Fri Jan 19, 2007 7:16 pm
Car: 2003 Infiniti G35 coupe (Skyline) Vortech Supercharged Jul 08 ROTM
Contact:

Post

I'll go with that.

tollboothwilley
Posts: 3759
Joined: Sun Aug 26, 2007 7:45 pm
Car: 2003 G35 Sedan w/ NAV
Location: LAS VEGAS!!!
Contact:

Post

I think that was well put Nate.

A good readers digest version of the 2nd half of this thread.

Either way, the Nissan Matic-S fluid is BETTER than the Nissan Matic-J.

That was the reason for this thread to begin with.

User avatar
Poyzinous
Posts: 2859
Joined: Mon Feb 02, 2009 9:56 am
Car: 2004 G35x Premium 1976 Classic Red 36 inch #18 Radio Flyer Wagon...
Location: Latitude 38.8* N, Longitude 77.1* W

Post

Ok Kev. I think I figured out your philosophy. I will attempt to explain it via visual aids, a caption for said visual aids,and sprinkle, lather, bake at 350*F in a preheated oven on a lightly oiled 2 inch deep pan for one hour.

According to you, nissan takes stuff from other companies and relabels it as their own. For example,Nissan goes to the dollar store (or worthy value store) and purchasesthe following oil for $2.50 a quart.

Neat huh? Yeah I wouldn't use this oil to torture my neighbors Honda. Excuse the foul language.

Here is The product!



I don't know about you, but I like fresh squeezed OJ with my breakfast. Not worm ridden grapefruit juice. It can cause UTI. 'member?Anyway, Nissan then(allegedly) proceeds to turn the product into their own creation...

They do a fairly good job as you can clearly see. Look at that detailJust marvelous.Could have fooled me...Anyway,So why is "Ester Oil" 3 times more than regular oil?Changing a black bottle is time consuming, and costs $3 worth of white out.Plus there is the labor intensive task of painting the darn bottle......But its totally worth it. The results are spectacular!So after letting the oil ferment and absorb the love, tenderness, and hard work into massaging it from its previous state, Ester Oil becomes a high quality oil specially formulated for your 9 thousand dollar engine.

Set to cool for 20 minutes before consuming. You may add your choice of cake frosting. Serves 1 to 1,000; depending on how you can slice your stuff...

If I had Matic S and some Castrol atf, I would have used them for my magnificent composition. Sorry Kev. When I get them I might do it for fun. This took me an hour to do. Anyway, hope you guys enjoyed it!


Modified by Poyzinous at 11:07 PM 8/12/2009

User avatar
Sentientbydesign
Posts: 6768
Joined: Wed Feb 02, 2005 8:21 am
Car: 03 Evo VIII - 330 AWHP
05 Subaru Legacy GT Stg 2 - Sold
05 G35 6MT Coupe - 278 WHP - Sold
04 WW Evo VIII - 302 AWHP - Ex's
96 I30 - Sold
Contact:

Post

I know Steve will love this:


User avatar
smockers83
Posts: 3889
Joined: Sat Oct 28, 2006 12:07 pm
Car: 2006 G35 Coupe

Post

Poyzinous, your logic is actually wrong. Take oil filters for example. Mobile1 oil filters are made by the same company with the same design as an oil filter that is sold for a lot less. There may be a very slight tweak, one that may not even be noticeable in the Mobile1 and the name of Mobile that increase the price.

What was that thread that had the study of oil filters in it?

Why does one power tool at Sears cost more than the exact same power tool that is at Wal-Mart? Here's what the manufacturer does. Say it's a drill. Drills have electric motors. An electric motor's capacity is based on how many times the motor is wound with copper. The motor in the drill at Sears will actually have more copper wire for its motor than the one at Wal-Mart.

I also agree with Nate in that there will be a bias towards Nissan/Infiniti from Nissan/Infiniti employees.

User avatar
smockers83
Posts: 3889
Joined: Sat Oct 28, 2006 12:07 pm
Car: 2006 G35 Coupe

Post

I should also mention that another reason for dealership fluids like Nissan Matic ATFs are jacked up in price due to economies of scale. If you want to know more about economies of scale, visit the Politics forum and check out the international trade thread.

When Nissan buys a fluid from a company that manufactures lubricants (lets face it, we all know Nissan doesn't manufacture its own ATF, brake fluid, oil, etc), they only sell that fluid through Nissan/Infiniti dealers, limiting their economies of scale, or almost put in a simpler way, their distribution potential. If Castrol does in fact manufacture Nissan's ATF, Castrol can sell its own fluid at a much cheaper price because it can sell a lot more of it through more distribution channels, such as retail stores (Wal-Mart, Target, etc.), auto parts stores (Autozone, Advanced Auto, etc.). Due to Nissan's limited distribution, they have to increase the price further in order to recoup their costs.

User avatar
Poyzinous
Posts: 2859
Joined: Mon Feb 02, 2009 9:56 am
Car: 2004 G35x Premium 1976 Classic Red 36 inch #18 Radio Flyer Wagon...
Location: Latitude 38.8* N, Longitude 77.1* W

Post

I know what you're talking about dude. The sears/walmart comparison... price difference... ok. Anyway, if I was allowed to disclose certain info, you would know other reasons why some stuff is more expensive at dealers. What I can tell you is that nissan development engineers don't just inflate prices from an equal product. There are minor(though fairly significant) variances in those products. Formulas aren't the same. Think about RC cola and Pepsi and Coke. All are caramel soft drinks with pretty much the same ingredients, but different variances, etc... The product that is bottled into one space isn't just poured into another one and given a different label. They go thru other little twitches and are given, special touches, so to speak, to differenciate them from a standard product. Comprende? somewhat? ok well soak it all in. The Ester oil post was just for fun. I was hoping to hear some compliments (and criticizms from the electrons in this molecule of G owners). But now that my buzz has died down I guess there are no longer seismic perceptions of my abience...

User avatar
G37 Man
Posts: 268
Joined: Sat Jan 05, 2008 3:29 pm
Car: G 37

Post

Poyzinous wrote:You I know what you're talking about dude. The sears/walmart comparison... price difference... ok. Anyway, if I was allowed to disclose certain info, you would know other reasons why some stuff is more expensive at dealers. What I can tell you is that nissan development engineers don't just inflate prices from an equal product. There are minor(though fairly significant) variances in those products. Formulas aren't the same. Think about RC cola and Pepsi and Coke. All are caramel soft drinks with pretty much the same ingredients, but different variances, etc... The product that is bottled into one space isn't just poured into another one and given a different label. They go thru other little twitches and are given, special touches, so to speak, to differenciate them from a standard product. Comprende? somewhat? ok well soak it all in. The Ester oil post was just for fun. I was hoping to hear some compliments (and criticizms from the electrons in this molecule of G owners). But now that my buzz has died down I guess there are no longer seismic perceptions of my abience...
You don't want me to start on the Ester oil issue again

I know Steve doesn't!

User avatar
smockers83
Posts: 3889
Joined: Sat Oct 28, 2006 12:07 pm
Car: 2006 G35 Coupe

Post

Poyzinous wrote:I know what you're talking about dude. The sears/walmart comparison... price difference... ok. Anyway, if I was allowed to disclose certain info, you would know other reasons why some stuff is more expensive at dealers. What I can tell you is that nissan development engineers don't just inflate prices from an equal product. There are minor(though fairly significant) variances in those products. Formulas aren't the same. Think about RC cola and Pepsi and Coke. All are caramel soft drinks with pretty much the same ingredients, but different variances, etc... The product that is bottled into one space isn't just poured into another one and given a different label. They go thru other little twitches and are given, special touches, so to speak, to differenciate them from a standard product. Comprende? somewhat? ok well soak it all in. The Ester oil post was just for fun. I was hoping to hear some compliments (and criticizms from the electrons in this molecule of G owners). But now that my buzz has died down I guess there are no longer seismic perceptions of my abience...
Eh, almost, but you're on the right track. Your example doesn't exactly work because RC Cola doesn't buy their syrup from Coke or Pepsi and change it.

I'm sure when Nissan orders its fluids from a manufacturer, they have specific specifications that may be different from the base fluid. A little more this, little less that. Nissan would have to inflate its prices on the fluids they bought and just rebranded without further enhancements. One, because they have to make a profit and two, well I've already gone into two. A further enhancement of the fluid, if any, would inflate the price even more to pay for Nissan's engineering.

There's also warranty issues involved with the price as well.
Modified by smockers83 at 9:59 PM 2/13/2009

User avatar
Sentientbydesign
Posts: 6768
Joined: Wed Feb 02, 2005 8:21 am
Car: 03 Evo VIII - 330 AWHP
05 Subaru Legacy GT Stg 2 - Sold
05 G35 6MT Coupe - 278 WHP - Sold
04 WW Evo VIII - 302 AWHP - Ex's
96 I30 - Sold
Contact:

Post

We're going to have to split this thread, but it's good convo, so I'll keep going.

With regards to the sears comparison...There's a little more applicable comparison with a better explanation. I bought a tool at Sears. It's a hand tool. It comes with a lifetime warranty. The price of the tool was $25 + tax.

Later that same day, I went across the street to Home Depot (damn do I hate that place) and I saw the EXACT same tool for $20. The size, shape, where the machining was done EVERYTHING except for two aspects... The Sears tool had a black textured grip whereas the HD had a blue "shiny" grip and the etching was different (Craftsman vs. XXX Brand).

So why was the Sears tool more? Because of the name and the warranty.

Poyzinous,

You'd be amazed how often products are distributed under a brand name and a generic name and sold a greatly differing prices. Actually a few brands specifically say "The makers of XXX do not make private label brands"

I love when BP owns Arco and Thrifty and one sells for higher than the other on opposing street corners.

Or, my all time favorite is when Intel and AMD started intentionally "breaking" their processors so that they could be sold for a lower price in a different category (Some of the on-board memory was physically severed to downgrade performance).

User avatar
SteveTheTech
Posts: 4505
Joined: Sat Aug 16, 2008 3:20 pm
Car: 15 Sentra SR
12 G37x Coupe
-Formerly-
05 Mazda 6 L3 Sport, 95 J30, 94 D22
Location: Chantilly, Va

Post

Sentientbydesign wrote:I know Steve will love this:
I would bathe in that, I mean it probably costs more than a bottle of really good Tequila. Stupid GTR fluid.

Nissan/Infiniti employees as a majority do not make any additional money if you do or do not buy Nissan OE fluids. Personally I do not care, it means nothing to me. I try to do my customers an additional service by replacing the fluids with the OE replacement if at all possible. It's what I use in my car and Acura OE fluids go in the wifes car. Maybe I am superstitious but that's me, it comes back to car Karma points.

As this thread progresses it is a good show case of the diversity of this group. It spurred an interesting debates. At the end of the day it matters more that your maintaining you car, than what your maintaining it with. It's your car do with it as you please. For some of you who swear off all dealer contact unless you either broke your car beyond repair or need something free by all means use whatever you think will work best. I do make money off repairing broken things, not the fluids you use. Just don't let price or marketing dictate your maintenance, be an educated consumer.

Poyzinous~I lol'd, get back to work

pfarmer
Posts: 1618
Joined: Mon Dec 15, 2008 9:03 am
Car: 2008 GXS with technology package
Contact:

Post

Sentientbydesign wrote:We're going to have to split this thread, but it's good convo, so I'll keep going.

With regards to the sears comparison...There's a little more applicable comparison with a better explanation. I bought a tool at Sears. It's a hand tool. It comes with a lifetime warranty. The price of the tool was $25 + tax.

Later that same day, I went across the street to Home Depot (damn do I hate that place) and I saw the EXACT same tool for $20. The size, shape, where the machining was done EVERYTHING except for two aspects... The Sears tool had a black textured grip whereas the HD had a blue "shiny" grip and the etching was different (Craftsman vs. XXX Brand).Poyzinous,

You'd be amazed how often products are distributed under a brand name and a generic name and sold a greatly differing prices. Actually a few brands specifically say "The makers of XXX do not make private label brands"

I love when BP owns Arco and Thrifty and one sells for higher than the other on opposing street corners.

Or, my all time favorite is when Intel and AMD started intentionally "breaking" their processors so that they could be sold for a lower price in a different category (Some of the on-board memory was physically severed to downgrade performance).
On the last part about processors one could actually compare many camcorders. For awhile during the vhs days you would find many which looked almost exactly alike. The difference was features would not be enabled on some. In the case of monitors many of the originals were done the same way right down to using the same circuit boards with sections not populated.

Now for a rebranded name that is a lot cheaper than the branded. I found out by accident that some of the batteries were rebranded right over the real brands label, haven't seen this in some time now. Now after doing a little bit of research I ran into something interesting. If you look at the warning labels you can find a brand sold by its side with a warning label worded exactly the same. Think about it a little bit and you can understand how and why that would occur even though the package was different.

As far as the economy of scale, I don't know if that is really true. Consider the cost of tires on a new car to the manufacturer compared to what they will resell you the tire for. There is no reason that Nissan, while not manufacturing the oil could not buy it in bulk for both their new cars, their service departments, and also use it to sell individually.

As far as the coke/pepsi comparison, do they actually bottle their own products, at least in all locations?

Perry


User avatar
smockers83
Posts: 3889
Joined: Sat Oct 28, 2006 12:07 pm
Car: 2006 G35 Coupe

Post

pfarmer wrote:As far as the economy of scale, I don't know if that is really true. Consider the cost of tires on a new car to the manufacturer compared to what they will resell you the tire for. There is no reason that Nissan, while not manufacturing the oil could not buy it in bulk for both their new cars, their service departments, and also use it to sell individually.
Sure it's true. Nissan's only customers are people with Nissans and Infinitis. They have only a limited market to sell to, a much smaller one than say Castrol, which can make a fluid for a number of different cars across different brands. For example, both Nissan and Subaru use the Matic J, but each one sells it to either people with Nissan or Subaru cars. Castrol on the other hand, can take a fluid and have it meet numerous specifications of different cars across different brands and sell it through many more distribution channels. The fact that Castrol can do that, it lowers the price they're able to charge because they can produce in much more bulk than Nissan and Subaru can buy it at and sell it to many more people. Castrol producing it in a higher amount and being able to sell it to many millions of more people than Nissan and Subaru combined allows them to produce it cheaper, charge a lower price, and still recoup all of their production costs.

If you want to learn more about it...zer...trade

User avatar
Poyzinous
Posts: 2859
Joined: Mon Feb 02, 2009 9:56 am
Car: 2004 G35x Premium 1976 Classic Red 36 inch #18 Radio Flyer Wagon...
Location: Latitude 38.8* N, Longitude 77.1* W

Post

While all of you make some good points, remember also that a 'multiple use' branded product is not always the same quality product as a dedicated use product. Auto companies are sneaky, they want to survive in this very competitive business, and prove it to each other. They will make something that requires a certain product, but tweak their something so that it will perform to 90 or 95% of its total potential without a certain specific balance or key secret ingredient. Thats what (with some maufacturers) differentiates the store product from the dealer product. They want to encourage specific applications to grow dedication. Its crazy how this thread blew up. I just wanted to tell everyone about the phaze out of matic J, and hear: 'gee whiz gabriel! thanx for telling me!' and 'golly gabe! thats good to know!' and 'jeebers dude! I'll ask for that next dealer visit!'.Instead we just stuffed a rapidly expanding gaseous mass of fun. Anyway, in conclusion, Castrol does not make matic S. Nippon oil does. Even with matic J, castrol's formula was different than Nissan matic J. Anyway, the good stuff has an unspecified(secret) percentage of super highly refined petroleum oil and mineral oil mists. Castrol doesn't even know if its 80% or 84%. it could be 80.237%. The rest is additives in undisclosed amounts and types. They refine and process it so it has a higher flash point than the cheap stuff you can buy, it also has a lower pour point temperature(good for you way up northern guys), and a fluid density that measures somewhere between .01 grams per cubic centimeter at 15*C, less than 3% fluid mass petroleum extract. I could go on, but i might be taken away in a white van and you guys will never hear from me again.Finally, buying castrol (instead of nissan) you will notice that even though they say you can use their stuff, they are still not totally confident in their own product, since they include a disclaimer stating they are not responsible for things that happen, and they offer no warranty coverage etc etc etc. okay everyone?CLASS DISMISSED!!!


pfarmer
Posts: 1618
Joined: Mon Dec 15, 2008 9:03 am
Car: 2008 GXS with technology package
Contact:

Post

smockers83 wrote:
Sure it's true. Nissan's only customers are people with Nissans and Infinitis. They have only a limited market to sell to, a much smaller one than say Castrol, which can make a fluid for a number of different cars across different brands. For example, both Nissan and Subaru use the Matic J, but each one sells it to either people with Nissan or Subaru cars. Castrol on the other hand, can take a fluid and have it meet numerous specifications of different cars across different brands and sell it through many more distribution channels. The fact that Castrol can do that, it lowers the price they're able to charge because they can produce in much more bulk than Nissan and Subaru can buy it at and sell it to many more people. Castrol producing it in a higher amount and being able to sell it to many millions of more people than Nissan and Subaru combined allows them to produce it cheaper, charge a lower price, and still recoup all of their production costs.

If you want to learn more about it...zer...trade
While Castro may sell more oil than Nissan buys for all its cars, it doesn't mean that Nissan is not utilizing 'economies of scale' in the selling of oil in individual quarts. Once the oil is purchased in bulk for their entire business then the economies of scale most affected could well be the packaging.

Take the case of tires. Not sure what the new cost is now, but at one time it was about 3 bucks a tire to the vehicle manufacturer at the same time they would be selling about 25 times that individually. One would think they would be selling individually what they purchase in bulk. If all new Nissans use the same oil new then you have that amount, plus all they use for oil changes, as well as what they sell individually, just like the tire example.

Perry

pfarmer
Posts: 1618
Joined: Mon Dec 15, 2008 9:03 am
Car: 2008 GXS with technology package
Contact:

Post

Poyzinous wrote:While all of you make some good points, remember also that a 'multiple use' branded product is not always the same quality product as a dedicated use product. Auto companies are sneaky, they want to survive in this very competitive business, and prove it to each other. They will make something that requires a certain product, but tweak their something so that it will perform to 90 or 95% of its total potential without a certain specific balance or key secret ingredient.
Consider the Jiffy Lube scene. You can go to Jiffy Lube and have your transmission fluid l changed. They will tell you it is the same stuff going back using their fluid with additives to match yours. Even if that is true do you trust them to get it right (consider who owns Jiffy Lube)? In the case of my Chrysler there was suppose to be something like seven different formulations for the transmission fluid using what Chrysler supplies, what you get is based on the transmission version, something I doubt they would take the time to figure out.

The difference in cost is a small price to pay for insurance.

Perry

User avatar
smockers83
Posts: 3889
Joined: Sat Oct 28, 2006 12:07 pm
Car: 2006 G35 Coupe

Post

pfarmer wrote:While Castro may sell more oil than Nissan buys for all its cars, it doesn't mean that Nissan is not utilizing 'economies of scale' in the selling of oil in individual quarts. Once the oil is purchased in bulk for their entire business then the economies of scale most affected could well be the packaging.
Never did I say Nissan wasn't utilizing their economies of scale. Anywhere.

What I said was...

Nissan has much smaller economies of scale compared to Castrol whether they utilize them or not (one would be stupid not to as they'd go bankrupt). If Castrol supplied Nissan with ATF with no alterations, Castrol would still be able to charge a lower price than Nissan. Granted Nissan also has to markup to recoup their costs. If all Castrol ATF was solely used for Nissans, they would sell at essentially the same price because their economies of scales are the same--the ones available in the Nissan market.

Added to this, Nissan also tries to take advantage of monopolistic benefits.
pfarmer wrote:The difference in cost is a small price to pay for insurance.
In that example, again you have economies of scale. To have 7 different formulations for each different transmission, Chrysler's cost of production goes way up to produce those 7 fluids, due to the economies of scale.

pfarmer
Posts: 1618
Joined: Mon Dec 15, 2008 9:03 am
Car: 2008 GXS with technology package
Contact:

Post

smockers83 wrote:
Never did I say Nissan wasn't utilizing their economies of scale. Anywhere.

What I said was...

Nissan has much smaller economies of scale compared to Castrol whether they utilize them or not (one would be stupid not to as they'd go bankrupt). If Castrol supplied Nissan with ATF with no alterations, Castrol would still be able to charge a lower price than Nissan. Granted Nissan also has to markup to recoup their costs. If all Castrol ATF was solely used for Nissans, they would sell at essentially the same price because their economies of scales are the same--the ones available in the Nissan market.

Added to this, Nissan also tries to take advantage of monopolistic benefits.

In that example, again you have economies of scale. To have 7 different formulations for each different transmission, Chrysler's cost of production goes way up to produce those 7 fluids, due to the economies of scale.
What is interesting here is that we are speaking of 7 different versions of the same transmission, however you could for the most part rebuild pretty much any of the transmissions using a specific rebuild kit.

I came across this problem on a 300 m site where someone would go to a Jiffy Lube type of business for fluid change, etc. and then the transmission would go nuts. Assuming no damage, changing it back and things may end up basically normal once more. They are very particular in what you put in them. I figure as often as you really need this service done, the dealer is a much safer place to have it done correctly.

Again cheap insurance. You may save 50 bucks at fluid change time or whatever only to pay a couple of thousand shortly thereafter. Even if exactly the same fluid going in which I doubt, the warranty may well be worth while.

Perry

User avatar
smockers83
Posts: 3889
Joined: Sat Oct 28, 2006 12:07 pm
Car: 2006 G35 Coupe

Post

I wasn't arguing which one you should buy, Nissan or Castrol. I was just trying to explain the main reason why Nissan's is expensive compared to stuff one can grab off the shelf.

pfarmer
Posts: 1618
Joined: Mon Dec 15, 2008 9:03 am
Car: 2008 GXS with technology package
Contact:

Post

smockers83 wrote:I wasn't arguing which one you should buy, Nissan or Castrol. I was just trying to explain the main reason why Nissan's is expensive compared to stuff one can grab off the shelf.
I didn't say you were. What I am pointing out is that it shouldn't be nearly so expensive unless it truely is far more expensive to produce since the actual difference in economies of scale at the individual unit probably doesn't justify the price difference if it is actually the same product.

On the other hand if the stuff really is different then it may in fact being sold at a very reasonable price. Other things come into play of course such as storage cost to the business, does it compete with other product placement, etc.

Regardless, even if the price is twice what it should be it still can become cheap insurance and may well be the real reflection of what justifies the cost to the consumer over brand 'x'.

Perry


User avatar
Poyzinous
Posts: 2859
Joined: Mon Feb 02, 2009 9:56 am
Car: 2004 G35x Premium 1976 Classic Red 36 inch #18 Radio Flyer Wagon...
Location: Latitude 38.8* N, Longitude 77.1* W

Post

Its official. Not available anymore. J matic is all gone. Get your Matic S 2day...

pfarmer
Posts: 1618
Joined: Mon Dec 15, 2008 9:03 am
Car: 2008 GXS with technology package
Contact:

Post

SteveTheTech wrote:For stock auto transmissions starting with the RE5 (02+Q) Nissan started using a different fluid with less detergents and slightly different additives.

If you are taking out the original valve body and replacing all of the seals, servos, and sealing devices. I would say you may be able to get away with something else but I wouldn't risk it if it were my car. Why risk it to save a few bucks if you are already building the trans?

This thread was started as an informative thread. If you want to start taking it off topic we can split it and you and poyzinous can sling mud at each other there.

Matic J and S are they only fluids that will not void your warranty
My guess is that with the price of a replacement/repair that a dealer just may have it tested to see if it is the correct fluid and unadulterated. Probably not all that hard since the mixture is known.

Perry

User avatar
SteveTheTech
Posts: 4505
Joined: Sat Aug 16, 2008 3:20 pm
Car: 15 Sentra SR
12 G37x Coupe
-Formerly-
05 Mazda 6 L3 Sport, 95 J30, 94 D22
Location: Chantilly, Va

Post

Most cases will not get to that point until they recall the part for a warranty examination. It doesn't happen all the time but when something that does not typically fail (ie an RE5) they may want it back or request a further investigation before a repair, like requesting any and all service records before approving any warranty claim. The failure is not technically a warranty issue. Click the image below to read more. The warranty information is standard and although you may able to pull the wool over their eyes, technically they do not have to replace anything for you that you have altered it in basically anyway or "improperly serviced" your car.



I'm not here to make money from anything. I am here as an Infiniti fan first and a technician second. What you do to your car is your prerogative I just want to keep all the Infinitis out there running correct.


Return to “G35 and G37 Engine, Drivetrain & Tuning”