mxr662 wrote: There seems to be many different ideas about it. Even found a post about possible design of a do-it-yourself transmission flush box. The BG shop in my area typically does not remove the pan and change the filter. They said the flush will clean what is in the pan. Did not want the crud in my pan to be flushed out possibly risking that some of it would be flushed back into the transmission.
Spent $51 for filter, gasket, and bolts from Joe. Five quarts ATF and an hour of my time that included an ATF shower at no extra charge.
Was able to wipe the magnet clean, which probably would not happen with a flush only. The fluid only became clean at the very end of the flush. Probably would have had to flush it twice to get it clean if only doing the flush.
5qt. new means you have over 5 qts. of dirty fluid in your transmission. That is not a mechanical fluid exchange! The pan is droppped so the sludge can be cleaned from it and examined for debris. What you did was a drain and fill.
qship96 wrote:who cares if there is a few particles caught in the screen,THATS WHAT IT IS DESIGNED FOR... if it ever trapped enough to impeed flow.... the tranny would already be needing a rebuild.
p.s. read qtech`s recent post on thoughts about the tranny screen replacement--- again I make my point about the importance of replacing the much finer filtering external filter,which will clog light years before the internal screen.BRIAN,have you replaced your external tranny filters on all your q45`s ???? member standards and beliefs do vary....
No, the screen is not for storing loose debris. It seems you missed Q45tech's post where he cut one "clean" screen open and examined it under a microscope. You also missed the post from a member who used Jerry Tucker who at the time didn't do the pan drop and filter screen replacement. After the mechanical fluid exchange, the member's car's tranmission cratered because of a blocked filter. Even if not blocked, the O ring ages and will not seal properly.
External filters replacements depend on ones maintainence standards. With regular mechanical fluid exchanges, pan drops and clean, and filter replacement, emprical eveidence suggests they last a minimum of 80K-100K.
Don't know on extended non-maintenance as those owner's don't change them anyway. Their transmissions just start malfunctioning then fail. Why Dennis says, "Member's standards vary."
You obviously have not read all of Q45tech's posts.