I decided on anodizing. It was a lot more expensive at $125 for the pair, but it'll be more sturdy than PC. There is a plating service in Newport News near the shipyard called Virginia Silver Plating that handled the job for me, and they supply a lot of marine services so I know the quality is good. Overall, I'm pleased. I went with a clear hard anodize, so these should hopefully not corrode again.

Before I had the bushings pressed out. Just generally dirty. The black stuff looks like something Nissan applied, like a paint. Not sure TBH. It can be sanded off, but not cleaned off.
Overall, I'm very happy with the way they came out. I had them sandblasted prior to dropping them off for anodizing, but the guys there media blasted them a second time with glass bead to give it a slightly smoother finish. The turn around time was a day to boot. I'm very happy with the quality of service I got from them. Pretty scratch resistant so far and they clean dirt and grime off easily. Now to get my Nismo rubber bushings in them and mate them up to these:
