5 Most Overrated Exercises You Can Skip

A General Discussion forum for cars and other topics, and a great place to introduce yourself if you are new to NICO!
User avatar
Looneybomber
Posts: 9140
Joined: Sun Mar 07, 2004 3:05 pm
Car: 02 explorer sprt (grn)
10 G37S (white)

Post

So school's out, temps are up, and pools are starting to open. That means folks are gonna want to get in shape after not using their gym membership from February till...well now. Over the last 14-15yrs, I've been weight lifting fairly consistently - sometimes obsessively and sometimes not at all to heal injuries from my "dedication". Over the years I've seen some fad lifts come and go, but, when I saw this article on weather.com, I had to post it here. For the general public, this article is so full of win because it touches on lifts I've griped about for years.

5 Most Overrated Exercises You Can Stop Doing
by Fiora Stevens on February 22, 2013

You’re a busy person, right? You want your time at the gym to be well spent, not wasted on exercises that won’t get you anywhere in terms of fitness or strength. Unfortunately, there’s a lot of misinformation out there, and that’s resulted in many of us using precious gym time doing things that are either totally useless or not as result-spurring as other options. Read on to find out which five overrated exercises you can cut from your gym routine.

1. Abdominal and side plank
Image

These core-focused exercises certainly have their uses for beginners: abdominal and side planks help strengthen core muscles and improve overall stability.

But because these are static bodyweight exercises (as in, you’re holding one position rather than flexing and unflexing your muscles), they quickly lose their potency once you reach a certain strength level, and then you’re pretty much just hanging out.

If you can already hold the plank for 30-60 seconds and you’re not looking to set a Guinness world record then try switching to exercises that challenge your stability dynamically, like a set of push-ups or more difficult variations of the plank.

2. Traditional Crunches.
Image

Note that in our dynamic exercise suggestion we did not mention crunches. While many people think that doing a hundred crunches a day will get them rock solid abs, it simply isn’t the case. Crunches only target one small abdominal muscle group, and can also place an undue amount of strain on the back and neck.

Think about adding some balance ball exercises to your routine instead, which tend to offer more variation and require more muscle action to stabilize your body with each movement.

3. Bench Press
Image

Although it’s a staple of gym buffs everywhere, the bench press is overrated mainly because too many beginners stick to this chest exercise thinking that it’s the only thing they need. But according to Poliquin Performance,

“As a general guideline – and this applies both to athletes and to the general population – never perform more than 20 percent of your training volume for pressing exercises from a [supine] position. In other words, 80 percent of your presses should be performed from other angles, such as with an incline or military press. Further, at least 50 percent of pressing exercises should be performed with dumbbells, as they offer a more natural movement pattern and provide a more challenging workout for the muscles that stabilize the shoulder.”


4. Seated knee extension
Image

Along with the leg press, the seated knee extension is one lower-body weight machine exercise that can be replaced with a way more effective substitute.

Like most weight machines, seated knee extensions target only one muscle group – in this case the quadriceps – in a motion that doesn’t translate well to other applications.

5. Hanging knee raise
Image

This is an exercise that’s got the opposite problem from some of those mentioned previously: it’s too hard for most of the people who try to do it, which means that unless you’ve got enough training experience under your belt, you’re probably not doing it correctly. Incorrect hanging knee raises not only fail to strengthen the muscles you’re intending to bulk up or tone, they also put you at risk for injury.

Read the full article here: http://dailyhealthpost.com/5-most-overr ... z2Ta4R9oRf

Now here's my opinion on everything.

#1. Planks.
Where the hell did these come from and how did they get popular? Here's another one of those fad lifts and I see poeple CONSTANTLY doing daily. 10+ yrs ago, you did not see people do planks in a gym! The article is so right about doing them for more than 1min. At that point, they're not doing you any good since your level of fitness is too advanced for that exercise.

#2. Traditional crunches.
The only time I do traditional crunches is when I have to get ready for a PT test. My best is 78 situps in a minute. Other than that, I do variations of it, typically with extra weight

#3. Bench.
Oh gosh bench is so over rated! 2-3 sets of it, and move to another lift. Most times, I don't do bench first on chest days like most folks do. Typically I start with incline dumbbell presses. Over building the chest makes a person more prone to shoulder injuries, which was one of two major issues with my shoulder back in '05. The other being repetitive motion from work.

#4 Leg extensions.
For the general public, who doesn't work their legs enough at all, this isolation exercise should be replaced with a good compound exercise. There's many to choose from.

For those dedicated strength training athletes, here is where I disagree. Leg extension is an excellent exercise to finish up a quad day (I do two leg days, one for quads, one for hams) with. After 4 sets of squats, hack squats, leg presses, and some lunges, you polish off those quads and forget about negotiating stairs. For a little "F-U Legs", do them first, and then try to do the rest of those compound exercises with fatigued quads.

#5. Leg/knee raise.
Once in a blue moon do I see someone doing these right. Most times they're swinging their legs back and using momentum to pull them up. They're arching their back and just being all crazy about it. Inevitably all they're doing is working their quads and hip flexors. Waste of time. Unless you're stopping before your legs are free hanging straight down and then curling your butt off of the back of the pad to really squeeze those abs, you're doing it wrong. Without momentum (think exploding at the bottom and swing legs as fast as possible) 98% of the people on that machine wouldn't be able to do that exercise right.


User avatar
PapaSmurf2k3
Site Admin
Posts: 19003
Joined: Thu Nov 21, 2002 3:20 pm
Car: 2017 Corvette, 2018 Focus ST, 1993 240sx truck KA Turbo.
Location: Merrimack, NH

Post

I can agree with most of that based on the results I've seen in the past, although evidently I was doing leg/knee raises correctly, cos that s*** worked (and was pretty tough)

User avatar
RCA
Posts: 8225
Joined: Mon Jan 22, 2007 8:09 am

Post

Looneybomber wrote:3. Bench Press
Although it’s a staple of gym buffs everywhere, the bench press is overrated mainly because too many beginners stick to this chest exercise thinking that it’s the only thing they need. But according to Poliquin Performance,

“As a general guideline – and this applies both to athletes and to the general population – never perform more than 20 percent of your training volume for pressing exercises from a [supine] position. In other words, 80 percent of your presses should be performed from other angles, such as with an incline or military press. Further, at least 50 percent of pressing exercises should be performed with dumbbells, as they offer a more natural movement pattern and provide a more challenging workout for the muscles that stabilize the shoulder.”
I do agree that most people rely too heavily on the bench press but it isn't something you should skip. Also the 80% presses stat isn't true for football players but for most athletes this is correct. I do agree with the dumbell presses instead of always relying on the barbell.

So "Overrated"? Yes.

"Exercises You Can Skip"? No.

Also how the heck did you/they miss the bicep curls? It makes up 95% of "bro" workouts since ever.

Solid list nonetheless.

User avatar
MinisterofDOOM
Moderator
Posts: 30928
Joined: Wed May 19, 2004 5:51 pm
Car: 1962 Corvair Monza
1961 Corvair Lakewood
1974 Unimog 404
1997 Pathfinder XE
2005 Lincoln LS8
Former:
1995 Q45t
1993 Maxima GXE
1995 Ranger XL 2.3
1984 Coupe DeVille
Location: The middle of nowhere.

Post

I can't stop something I never started.

User avatar
AZhitman
Administrator
Posts: 54542
Joined: Mon Apr 29, 2002 2:04 am
Car: 58 L210, 63 Bluebird RHD, 64 NL320, 65 SPL310, 66 411 RHD, 67 WRL411, 68 510 SR20, 75 280Z RB25, 77 620 SR20, 79 B310, 90 Z32, 91 GTi-R, 92 Silvia Qs, 98 S14, 23 Z.
Location: Surprise, Arizona
Contact:

Post

The only one I disagree with is #1... We did these religiously in Kenpo, incorporating alternating leg lifts and arm lifts. Great for balance and core. I got up to 6 minutes... Granted, they're right in that there are other, better, core exercises once you 'master' it, but for someone getting back into core training, it remains a staple.

We called it Chinese TV Watching. :)

This reminds me - I need to get off my a$$ and get some exercise. :(

User avatar
Looneybomber
Posts: 9140
Joined: Sun Mar 07, 2004 3:05 pm
Car: 02 explorer sprt (grn)
10 G37S (white)

Post

RCA wrote:I do agree that most people rely too heavily on the bench press but it isn't something you should skip. Also the 80% presses stat isn't true for football players but for most athletes this is correct. I do agree with the dumbell presses instead of always relying on the barbell.

So "Overrated"? Yes.

"Exercises You Can Skip"? No.
Dealing with ongoing shoulder issues, flat bench is something I skip every once in a while. However, it's a very rare day for me to skip incline dumbells. It's a good exercise, no reason to eliminate it entirely, but unlike squats, it shouldn't be a focal point and there's no reason you couldn't skip it every once in a while.
RCA wrote:Also how the heck did you/they miss the bicep curls? It makes up 95% of "bro" workouts since ever.
If you said preacher/iso curls, then I'd say yes, but since there's 30 varieties of bicep curls, I can't say skip bicep curls. But, you're right, like bench, "bros" place waaay too much importance on any bicep exercise and typically over work their bi's anyway. Though, over building your bi's isn't as bad for your posture as overbuilding your chest is.

Remember though,
Image

User avatar
RCA
Posts: 8225
Joined: Mon Jan 22, 2007 8:09 am

Post

Looneybomber wrote:it shouldn't be a focal point and there's no reason you couldn't skip it every once in a while.
Yeah I agree. It's just the title that threw me off a bit.
Looneybomber wrote:I can't say skip bicep curls. But, you're right, like bench, "bros" place waaay too much importance on any bicep exercise and typically over work their bi's anyway. Though, over building your bi's isn't as bad for your posture as overbuilding your chest is.

Remember though,
http://weknowmemes.com/wp-content/uploa ... eg-day.jpg
I would say skip it. If you have a day when you do back, then you don't need a bicep workout. Pull-ups and any pull based sets are more then enough. After my back/shoulders day at the gym (7 total sets), I usually do some sort of bicep super set. Biceps make up probably 5 mins of my entire back/shoulders day.

Also sh*tty story about that image...
http://i.imgur.com/m3mO89D.png


Image

User avatar
WDRacing
Moderator
Posts: 15983
Joined: Mon Nov 25, 2002 2:00 am
Car: 95 240SX, 99 BMW 540i, 01 Chevy Express, 14 Ford Escape
Location: MFFO
Contact:

Post

Planks are great for core building. If you don't think so, ask a Navy SEAL, PJ or STS member.

If you're rushing around in the gym, you're doing something wrong. Make time for yourself, do it the right way.

For the vast majority of people looking to burn fat and build some lean muscle mass, you can do all of that without even setting foot in the gym. I use...ok used to use, dumb bells and a chin up bar that's it and a bunch of exercises that rely on body weight, like the p90x routine, accept there was no p90x back then.

I've never liked going to the gym, hate would be a better description.

For the lazy people, you can try my couch potato routine. For every commercial, get up and do 20 situps/20 pushups/20 jumping jacks or standing squats with a chair or whatever. Increase reps and or add items in as you improve your fitness level.

User avatar
MinisterofDOOM
Moderator
Posts: 30928
Joined: Wed May 19, 2004 5:51 pm
Car: 1962 Corvair Monza
1961 Corvair Lakewood
1974 Unimog 404
1997 Pathfinder XE
2005 Lincoln LS8
Former:
1995 Q45t
1993 Maxima GXE
1995 Ranger XL 2.3
1984 Coupe DeVille
Location: The middle of nowhere.

Post

WDRacing wrote:I've never liked going to the gym, hate would be a better description.
THIS. The appeal of gyms to me is right up there with the appeal of the Fiat Multipla.
Image

User avatar
Jesda
Posts: 39644
Joined: Mon May 05, 2003 1:50 pm
Location: STL, DTW
Contact:

Post

I like to play outside. I enjoy fresh air, the lake, the sky, the boobies on the joggers. I even adjusted the handlebar height on my bike to enable me to sit up and see more of the scenery.

Unfortunately, the only lifting I do is when I put my bike in the back of the Saab.


Return to “General Chat”