Post by
elwesso »
https://forums.nicoclub.com/elwesso-u5248.html
Fri Apr 04, 2014 12:19 pm
I just replaced my Q for daily driver use with an 07 G35. I required a sedan with a manual transmission, and did not want another CTS-V. Honestly, I really like the G35. I'm about 6'2 and I have plenty of space in the G. Just took it on a 1000 mile road trip and it was very nice. Seats are a little narrow, but they're very supportive... I averaged about 25-26MPG, which is unreal for me, I've never owned a car that gets that good fuel economy.
The G35 has a very refined drivetrain, it's bullet proof reliable, and it's got the perfect blend of quiet and luxurious and sporty feel. IMO, it's got a better blend than the BMW 3 series or 5 series. I think it's got about as much space as the 5 series, but feels a lot more nimble.
I still have the Q and drive it from time to time, but it's got a laundry list of things that needs replaced, and the rust is starting to get bad (worse than I thought).
Honestly I love the exterior of the Y34 M45, but the interior sucks. It's like the 03-05 G35, which IMO is kind of cheap, and the seats are still kind of narrow. Many people complain about the location of the seat controls too (on the inside on top of the seat).
If you can afford it, the new generation M37 and M56 are a great buy. You can find 2011 M56 for under 30k with less than 60k miles. 25MPG highway with 420HP is fantastic. That would have been the car I would have got if you could get it in an MT. The M37 is a great car too, but I'd probably go with the M56. The drivetrain is proven in the QX. I'd seriously consider that.
IMO, there's not a car on the market today that compares to the 1st gen Q. The 2nd gen Q is still very well made, but still not as good as the 1st gen. Point is, most anything post 2005 is gonna seem like junk compared to the old Q45.